I have been raising, training and handling k-9s for 25 years and I know the value of good nutrition on performance and health. This product content has been consistent since I started purchasing. In today's world, that's a big deal. Who knows about the future, but for now this product is a very good value and good for the k-9s.

I've been using this dog food now for about six months. Both dogs like it. Couple days ago, my Miniature Schnauzer's mouth was full of blood and she was very distressed I found a sharp Shard of bone stuck between her tooth and gum. After closer inspection, I found lots of sharp shards of bone mixed in with the kibble and embedded in pieces of kibble. I guess Salmon bones are soft until they dry everything out then they become a hazard. I will not buy this food anymore. I reported this to my vet. She says that these little sharp pieces can cut or puncture the throat stomach and digestive tract. Please beware.

After we got another dog, buying blue buffalo became a steep monthly bill. We tried Natured Recipe Grain free with pumpkin and after the Smuckers recall we decided to switch. My Dutch shepherd had awful gas with blue and nature's, just awful and embarrassing when we had company and she would fog a room. Both her and my German shepherd always seemed a bit itchy and with the Members mark Salmon I have seen marked improvement in their scratching and shedding. The Dutch also doesn't have the gas she did before. Very happy that my beloved Sam's started carrying this.

My dogs have done well on several varieties of Members Mark food over many years. They are healthy and I receive compliments in their beautiful coats. While the quality is good, the financial value has diminished. Members mark dog food went from 40 lb bags at $14 to $35 for a 30lb bag in 20 years. It far exceeds inflation

This is one of the only dog foods we have found that does not have chicken meal in the ingredients (our dog has a poultry allergy). So it is awesome. But my dogs are not crazy about the taste. They eat it only when they are super hungry and turn their nose up at it otherwise.

We first tried this dog food because the ingredient list seemed similar to the brand NutriSource but it was a few dollars cheaper so we wanted to try it out. After slowly transitioning between foods our dog seemed fine. After she was 100% off the old food she started to have diarrhea which got a point that we needed to take her to the vet. They have to give her what was basically a dog probiotic to help firm her poops which was only temporary because once she was done with those the diarrhea was back. After eliminating all other options we decided to go buy a bag of her old food and cold turkey feed nothing but that to her. Overnight(2 meals back on her old food) she is having her regular firm poops again. So needless to say this food gave her terrible diarrhea for weeks and ended up costing us $100 in a vet visit so go with something else!

Bought it to try with my dogs who had been eating more expensive salom based grain free dog food . Mixing 50/50 to allow them to adjust to new food provide water free choice . They like it, no problems so far. I like cost difference and resealable bag. Small kibble size.

I switched to this grain free brand since the price was great compared to other grain free brands at the pet stores. My little boy loves it but the girl won't eat it. Maybe she doesn't like the fishy smell. She will eat the grain free chicken with pea recipe.

I was so happy to see that Sam's Club has joined the competitive healthy pet food world, and has come up with several flavors of AFFORDABLE & grain free dry food that I bought over one month ago for my 3 German Shepherd dogs. they love their food so far, and there have been zero issues. I'd love to see them expand into the healthy canned food world. ps.... don't forget about the kitties @ Sam's Club.

The first ingredient in this dog food is salmon. Although it is a quality item, raw salmon contains a lot of water. After cooking, most of that moisture is lost, reducing the meat content to just a fraction of its original weight. This product gets most of its protein from chickpeas and peas. Not good enough for over $30 a bag.