I used to feed the dog science diet! Yikes! That's what he came home on, so I didn't want to give him upset tummy, I slowly mixed grain free! Salmon & pea and he's been happy ever since. Then I got a second dog... they've been on this food for years. It is sometimes hard to find. 6 years... last about a month for 2. They use a lil more in winter months. & they are correct it doesn't smell fishy anymore! But my fur kids still love it! Thank you Sam's

I have a pack of Toy Poodles with all the fussiness you'd expect from little Poodles. I bought a bag of this food on the spur of the moment and was a little concerned when I opened the bag at home that the kibble was larger (it's medium size, really) than what I figured my fussy, toothless crew could manage. But I put some bowls of it down and, hey!, they dug right into it, no problem. They love the stuff! So, it works for them just fine. And it works for me because what comes out the other end is tiny little tootsie rolls and easy to pick up. Win/win situation! :-)

I have generally stayed away from added grains to my dog food. This provides fiber and bulk through peas, which I believe are a better source of fiber. It took a couple of weeks for my German Short Haired Pointer to adapt but he is processing it well. I got him as a 11 month old, he had previously been fed Kibble, a cheap dog food. His coat is healthier looking though he still appears to be adapting to it and will not finish the bowl of 3.5 cups in one sitting. This is an excellent value for the price point, most very good dog foods have 50%+ protein, at 43% and this price it is not shabby.

I was a bit hesitant when I switched to this food because I haven't tried anything like it before and I have one picky eater (a chihuahua of course) and another dog that likes to graze on his food throughout the day. It's been about a month since I've transitioned them to this food and they BOTH scarf it down right away which was not the case with previous food. I switched because my chihuahua was exhibiting symptoms of food intolerance with constant ear infections, so I'm hoping this helps clear that up. So far, so good. Also, I was concerned that the size of the kibbles would be too big for my small dogs, but they are just right. I'm really satisfied with this product.

I am going to compare this food to purina pro plan for sensitive stomach. I used to buy pro plan for my Bassett hounds but I now have a husky which is very sensitive. He was getting very itchy and throwing up, I switched to this and now he looks and feels much better. I would definitely recommend this food and for the price you cannot get anything better. My dog and I are loving this food, I will continue to purchase.

Between the massive price hike and the fact that they reformulated, we will no longer be purchasing this. Our dogs LOVED this dog food before. Our pups have been feeding them this consistently for 2+ years. They used to get SO excited to eat it! Now they will only take a few bites at night. Which is really bad considering they only get fed once a day. It no longer smells like fish, my pups hate eating it, it has made them have diarrhea, etc We also strictly carried a Sams membership because of how great this dog food was. We will for sure not be renewing in November.

My dog Vinny has been eating Member's Mark Exceed Grain Free Dry Dog Food for a couple years now. It is the only dog food that I buy. I like that it is made in the USA and is grain free. It has plenty of Omega 3 fatty acids and leaves his coat looking shiny and healthy. It has a nice texture and the pieces are nicely sized. I also like that by feeding my dog Member's Mark Exceed he is not getting any preservatives or artificial coloring.

Switched from an expensive grain free food to this one after comparing and reading the reviews, my dogs love it! Frenchie with sensitive stomach & allergies has no issues, doesn't make my dogs gassy & leaves their coats so shiny! So glad to have found this!!

This arrived today and I was excited because recently my dog has become very picky and will not eat his normal food. I put a spoonful in his bowl and he sniffed it and walked away. Will be taking this back. I wish they offered sample sizes to try first.

I have been trying so many different "high quality" expensive dog food from the pets stores to help my dog from excessively shedding. None of them worked and since shes a bloodhound and eats it was getting pretty pricey. After looking at the ingredients (which are great!) I thought I'd give this food a try. My dog loves it! And after using one bag of the salmon flavored one he shedding had drastically reduced! I'm hooked!