Not too hard, but hard enough to help clean Rocky's teeth. He loves the taste.

Our German shepherd loves These as a treat. Made from good ingredients.

My dog loves it.

My doodle with allergies loves these treats. At this price point, I am happy to give them to all of my dogs and they gobble them up.

My dogs really like these but it's made their stools very runny. I suspect it must be the pumpkin ingredients.

My dog loves these peanut butter treats! They are made from all natural ingredients, very healthy treats!

Haven’t tried them, but the dogs seem to like them! Don’t know they have ever turned down a treat though?

This is the second time I bought these and my dog will not eat them. She takes it in her mouth, looks at me, and drops it on the floor.

Our dogs love these but they arrived all broken. We have bullies and we have to count our fingers when we give them these treats.

My dog loves these!