Healthy and my dogs love them. I love the limited ingredients. Too bad they are being discontinued. The newer version has more ingredients and cinnamon and there is no way of knowing the the cinnamon has lead in it. With all the concerns about cinnamon I'm not sold on giving them to my dog. I'm going they bring these back!

Their simple, wholesome ingredients make them a healthy option for my two furry friends. My two dogs absolutely love the peanut butter flavor, and the treats are oven-baked for a fresh taste. Overall, they offer a great balance of quantity, quality and affordability. Perfect for rewarding my two boys after a successful trip outdoors!

I bought these for my grand-dog she comes to visit and I like giving her a treat she is a red nosePitBull and takes her treats very seriously.I had to look for certain things because she has allergies. And this treat fit the list. She loves them and while she can only have 2 on her visits she always comes and ask for more. A great find and love the ingredients.

Our pack loves these healthier treats! They are just the right size for our big dogs, not too big or little, just enough for multiple treats throughout the day. I appreciate that the ingredients are better than most on the market and they are made in the USA.

I've been feeding these as a treat for our two small dogs for several years. I break the bone-shaped treats into 6 or 7 pieces. It's too bad that the price on these has gone from $10 to $15 dollars/box since the pandemic.

Great quality treat with ingredients I understand and that my dog loves! It is tough to find good quality treats at a reasonable price, and these do it.

While the quantity of product is adequate for the price my dog was not impressed with the product and it took quite a while to get him to eat any of it. Since I have not tried one myself I cannot give a definitive evaluation of the flavor but I trust that my dog's reluctance to try the product speaks for itself.

It's a pity I had to have these dog treats shipped to my house. I originally bought them at Sams club in person. When I went to buy them again a person working at Sams told me if I wanted them, I'd have to order them online, I did, they arrived all broken in small pieces!!! Not like when I got them at Sams club.

I’ve been buying these treats for several years! Pups usually love them!! Last box I bought at Sam’s was literally burnt hard! Pups can’t eat them even if I soak them! Yes they will be returned!! I noticed several boxes had been opened at display rack when I purchased this box! I should have known something was wrong at that time!! Check box before you leave store or simply return. Usually the treats are a light golden color and break easily. This last box of treats is brown and ROCK HARD!!

Have been buying these for our dog for the last 6 years, and always satisfied. This time the biscuits seemed to be a little different texture and both bags were 60 percent broken. Will be looking for a better quality product next time.