Healthy and my dogs love them. I love the limited ingredients. Too bad they are being discontinued. The newer version has more ingredients and cinnamon and there is no way of knowing the the cinnamon has lead in it. With all the concerns about cinnamon I'm not sold on giving them to my dog. I'm going they bring these back!

It's a pity I had to have these dog treats shipped to my house. I originally bought them at Sams club in person. When I went to buy them again a person working at Sams told me if I wanted them, I'd have to order them online, I did, they arrived all broken in small pieces!!! Not like when I got them at Sams club.

I’ve been buying these treats for several years! Pups usually love them!! Last box I bought at Sam’s was literally burnt hard! Pups can’t eat them even if I soak them! Yes they will be returned!! I noticed several boxes had been opened at display rack when I purchased this box! I should have known something was wrong at that time!! Check box before you leave store or simply return. Usually the treats are a light golden color and break easily. This last box of treats is brown and ROCK HARD!!

My Dogs love them! They are easy to break apart if you have smaller dogs. I get three to four treats out of one.

Our Maltese is a very finicky eater. Until now, we’ve never found a dog biscuit that she would consistently eat. This one is different!

Used to purchase these treats at Sam's club (no longer available) only online for additional 8 dollars shipping. They appeared to have changed the recipe. They were sturdier. More were broken than intact.

We just received our box and there are two plastic bags inside full of random sized broken pieces. This can't be shipping damage, so definitely not what we were expecting. The dogs seem to like them.

I used to buy these in the store when they had them in-store. Now they are only online for shipping. The problem w this is that the shipping process breaks "most" of the dog biscuits. I have a large dog that wants the full biscuit and I don't want to deal with all the broken pieces when giving them out as treats. I estimate that 70% of the dog biscuits are broken now that they can only be shipped to you as a Members Mark product. They should sell these in the store and this would alleviate this problem. Really frustrating.

Our dogs love these treats and the ingredients are natural and understandable... we’re all sold

Barkley and Wishbone love these, they don't have any unnecessary ingredients