I buy these regularly and other than breaking easily, they have always been good. However the package I bought recently had numerous burned biscuits and pieces. Not sure how these ever passed quality control. You might want to check the package before purchasing and avoid a trip back to the club.

My dog loves these and they are a good price

I did not care for these dog biscuits.

When I offered one of these to my dog she looked at me like it was an insult. I tried covering it with peanut butter, but she licked off the peanut butter and left the crumbled up biscuit on the floor. She is not picky and loves everything from peanut butter to pizza crust, but she abhors these "treats". Makes me wonder if they were tested with real dogs.

My dog was sick for 2 days , could stop throwing up, had to take to vet!

Trusted treats for our pups

I had great hopes for these, but my two pups will not eat them. I am hard-pressed to think of anything else my dogs will NOT eat.

All my dogs love them.

I bought this despite some of the reviews stating their dogs did not like it. I figure I’d give it a try since my 2 of my 3 dogs are not particular with their snacks. They won’t eat it! Won’t buy it again.

Hv bought for years. They all loved them. These 5 boxes are a lighter color. Seem to have peanutbutter FLAVORING. What happened to REAL peanutbutter? I have 11 rescues. 2 are vomitting. The others don't want them. What did they do?