Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark 5-Burner Propane Gas Grill w/ Cover for
Member's Mark 5-Burner Propane Gas Grill w/ Cover

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 11-20 of 32 reviews
May 11, 2026
Allen
3 out of 5 stars review

Quality appears to be good but......

This grill appears to be good quality after assembling it. It took two of us about 7 to 8 hours to assemble it, test it for leaks and fire it up for the first time. It heats up quickly and the side burner is a nice extra, but we probably won't use it for much. I will update this review if after actually grilling food if it is not as it should be. I would have rated it higher but as of right now it gets 3 stars because of the grueling assembly time and complications. Some holes were not threaded correctly, and screws would not go in. Some holes did not line up with where they should have to bolt pieces together, the side burner unit is cockeyed because of this, but it did work after we decided to "call it good enough". Everything should be perfect on this grill though as these grills are not cheap! We DID LOVE that it came with a cover! Our first Members Mark grill similar to this one had lasted 6 years. We hope this one will too.

Helpful?6HRZ4IZGQVFS17884905831
May 5, 2026
Jarrod
4 out of 5 stars review

Overall, seems worth it for the price.

Assembly took roughly 1hr 45 min solo. The overall assembly isn't bad, but some holes weren't punched and threaded properly. That added 15mins and luckily I had the tools for it. The grill so far seems really good for the price. The included cover is garbage. Just putting it on for the first time and there's 5 holes were sunlight comes through at the seams. These aren't the “vent” holes, it's just bad. Anytime I go to upload a photo, the Sams app throws errors.

Helpful?6HRZ4IZGQVFS17884905831
May 20, 2026
MICHAEL
3 out of 5 stars review

Bought on sale

For the price, it's a great product. During assembly, an arm used to position the side burner fell off. It didn't prevent final assembly and doesn't interfere with the burner's operation. The included cover is pretty cheap and has a tear on one of the seams. For cooking, the grill seems to run hot. However, I'm used to a CharBroil 'infrared' style with diffuser plates under the grill plates. My issue with this grill is how it handles rain with the lid closed. Without a cover, water pools in the grease catcher from the large plate under the burners. No significant water should be able to drip into the interior like it does. Once this grill is broken in, that water would be nasty.

Helpful?6HRZ4IZGQVFS17884905831
May 8, 2026
Ramona
5 out of 5 stars review

Jonas at the Provo location is awesome

I ordered this grill online during the doorbuster sale. My pick-up order from the Provo, Utah location was cancelled the morning that I was supposed to pick it up, but I went into the store to ask about it at customer service anyway. The guy at customer service was not helpful at all but the curbside pick-up worker, Jonas, was super helpful and went above and beyond to help me with my order. I really appreciated all the effort he put in to help me get my grill! I didn't catch his managers name, but she was also helpful in fixing the cancelled order. Thank you Jonas! You're awesome and I can't wait to get grilling!

Helpful?6HRZ4IZGQVFS17884905831
Apr 5, 2026
JEREMY
2 out of 5 stars review

Nice but it won't stay that way for long!

Here is an honest assessment of the grill after using it for one season. Overall, it is serviceable and cooks food well. However, after a month, the doors began to show rusting. Now, the top of the grill is completely faded from where the cover sat on the top. I'm not sure what would cause this. It has always been covered while in the elements. I would not recommend this. It looks great when new. But, for $400, this should last better!

Helpful?6HRZ4IZGQVFS17884905831
May 1, 2026
Skip
3 out of 5 stars review

Do your homework before you buy.

Not exactly sure if this is the same as last year but after a year of using it my observations and dislikes are : No grease tray to pull out and clean. I should have caught this in the store when I looked at the floor model. You cannot get to the drip tray without partially taking the grill apart. I also hate that the back of the grill is Open to the elements ! Another thing I should have caught. I would not have purchased this grill. I've had several MM grills in my life and this is the worst one sadly. It does not get hot enough either on the side without the searing bar. Also as noted in other reviews the cover holds condensation under it. I may end up getting rid of it this year and buying a Weber from my local Ace Hardware store which comes fully assembled and delivered.

Helpful?6HRZ4IZGQVFS17884905831
May 4, 2026
stone
4 out of 5 stars review

No back on grill I will review after I use it

Just put it together. There is 2 foot gap on back that animals can easily get in. I decided to take off the back of my old grill and modify to fit this grill. Can't have an animal hotel in my grill.

Helpful?6HRZ4IZGQVFS17884905831
Feb 25, 2026
Leo
1 out of 5 stars review

Leaks grease every where

Leaked grease from all four corners after only one summer season of use . I only use my grill to make hamburgers and chicken a few times during the summer season. Felt nice and sturdy when I put it together but over poorly built and terrible quality.

Helpful?6HRZ4IZGQVFS17884905831
Mar 28, 2026
Heather
5 out of 5 stars review

Good value for when you're on a budget

So far, I think this grill is a good value for the money. It was missing a handle in the box, but I called the number included with the grill and they replaced it quickly with no problems. I would recommend this grill if you want to save a little money but still get a good product. I like that it came with a cover as well.

Helpful?6HRZ4IZGQVFS17884905831
Feb 26, 2026
Le0
5 out of 5 stars review

I got this grill for a good price. The quality is top notch. the assembly instruction manual is well written with good accurate illustrations. the manual has a breakdown of all the necessary parts. I downloaded the BILT app to assist in assembling the grill and the app was very useful and interactive. I used the grill twice so far and I've been satisfied with it

Helpful?6HRZ4IZGQVFS17884905831