My dog was in love with the taste of the peanut butter ones. He would eat them all if I'd let him. I was really hoping these would be the answer to his fear of loud noises but I gave him 2 a day religiously for 90 days and I didn't notice one bit of difference. He's still terrified of storms and fireworks and flies in his kennel and shakes when these events are happening. I even gave him a double dose on July 4th and the weekend of and still nothing. I won't buy a third container and I'm certain my pup will be sad about it because he loooooves them. They're too expensive to buy as just treats though :(

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have 5 dogs, 3 of which can get anxious from time to time. When using these treats I did notice a difference in their behavior but nothing too drastic. My dogs can be somewhat picky when it comes to treats and it took a little while before they wanted to try these. At times I would put a bit of peanut butter on it and they enjoyed that better. Not sure what was putting them off about these. Overall I think these are great calming treats. *I received this product for free in exchange for an honest review.*

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Thanks BzzAgent & Zesty Paws for the free sample! I was excited to receive these Zesty Paws Calming Bites Plus to help my dog with his separation anxiety when I leave the house, but unfortunately, they didn't work for us. I followed the dosage instructions, but I didn't notice any difference in his behavior, he was just as anxious as before. On top of that, he didn't like the taste, so getting him to eat them was a struggle. Unfortunately, this product didn't work out for us.

I have two rescue pups and even though I've had them for a few year the separation anxiety hasn't gone away. I used these for both of them, 1 is 110lbs and the othe is 15lbs, and they worked amazingly. I can't believe how much calmer they seem. This is definitely a product I will be purchasing over and over again.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I used with my 4 very large dogs. I have tried other calming treats that never seem to work on one of mine, this product actually seemed to help him. He tends to be bothered by easily and after his calming snack, he was less agitated. Even my picky eater liked it, I wish they didn't crumble as much and were a more uniform size.

My pup has anxiety and was looking for some help. My pup really likes these and after having one seems to settle not have some of the symptoms I have noticed with the anxiety. The container is a lot bigger then I thought it would be which is a plus. A real value and since it seems to be helping will order more.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] (i have received this product as part of a promotion in exchange for an honest review) my pup has never really had trouble sleeping but recently had some anxiety with his dad being away for a while. as soon as he left on the trip, sparky was very anxious and didn't want to relax, waiting for his dad. i gave him one (17lbs) and within 30 minutes, he was relaxed and hanging out with me on the couch. he continued to get one the first five nights and didn't need them after. now, he gets them during thunderstorms. he really likes them!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dog is anxious and has separation anxiety so I have tried a few dog calming products in hopes to relieve some of the issues we are having with her. One we tried was much too strong and I found it made her looked glossy eyed and drugged and others I found not effective at all. These calming bites are a perfect fit for her. I have found it takes the edge off and she is less anxious and calm without acting sedated. She seems to also really like the taste of them and gets excited when I grab the bag. She is 22 pounds and only needs one treat.

My dog is so picky and so energetic these treats came in so handy. I've honestly noticed the difference in his energy level. I've also noticed the improvement in his anxiety levels. Him having this treat helps me feel better about leaving him at home while I'm working.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I can't say enough good things about The Calming Plus Bites! My dog Anya absolutely loves the taste, which is always a win. More importantly, these treats have made a noticeable difference in her anxiety levels throughout the day. Anya has always struggled with anxiety, and ever since I started giving her these bites, I've seen her become much calmer and more relaxed. It's such a relief to find a product that not only she enjoys but also effectively helps her feel at ease. Highly recommend for any pet parent looking to help their furry friend manage anxiety!