[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have two large cane corsos and I tried these treats for them to see if they had a more calming effect on them. I didn't think I saw any change is calming activity, but they did enjoy eating them with no problem. Maybe they need more than the recommended amount but I didn't want to give more for the trial.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This product is far and away the best of its kind. I had honestly given up on similar products because, in the past, I did not find them to be useful with my two large mixed breed dogs. I received the Calming Plus Bites in exchange for writing a detailed, honest review of the product. And to be honest, I am amazed. My dogs love the treats and they truly do have a calming effect on my pets. I live in a suburban area and there are lots of other dogs in our area, which usually means a lot of barking inside and outside of my house. With these treats, my dogs are no longer responding negatively to the noises around them. These will definitely become a staple of our household shopping list!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Dog enjoys the taste. Haven't been able to see the calming effect yet. Doggo is 15 lbs and I gave her 2 treats. After about 20 minutes I had a friend come over and she was still fiesty. I will see if it works during the upcoming 4th of July.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] These treats have been a great addition to our routine. My dogs are picky at times, and won't eat healthy treats, but they love these. My 3 year old pup suffers with separation anxiety, and barking, and nothing had helped, until now. His barking has significantly reduced, and alot of the negative habits have dissipated. I found my pup to be happier and less stressed out. And the best part of all, is that they love the treats! Win over all.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Upon opening the bag, the smell was ok and not offensive like some treats can be. My dog was very unsure at first and smelled them and walked away. He came back for them, took one and then dropped it. I'm not sure why he was unsure but he did end up eating it. He will eat them now but they are not what he will choose first over other treats. I also do not see calming effects. I have a very high energy GSP with anxiety, I would hope this could work for another breed of dog.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received this product for free in exchanve for my honest review. I really wanted this to work for my senior dog. He's had really horrible anxiety since we had to say our goodbyes to his brother. He loved the taste of these, but we did not see any improvement in him with their use. They also arrived with a good chunk of the bag crumbled into little pieces so that was annoying.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have a very large Labrador, who is TERRIFIED of storms, shakes like a leaf. I received this product the morning of a day when a huuuuge storm was about to hit my city. With my big boy, the bag said 3 calming bites, I gave them to him, and I could tell about 45 minutes later how much calmer he was, I did end up giving him 1 more through the course of the night, which seems to be the right dose for my boy. Needless to say, great product.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I gave my 3 year old 75 lb Belgian Malinois the appropriate amount of the calming treats. She absolutely loves them. She ate each one with no issues. She rested well and wasn't running arms as she usually does.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have a 9 yr old super reactive pup with high anxiety when left alone... these bites are fantastic in conjunction with his meds. He slept for a full 3 hours after me leaving (which he's never done before!). Would highly recommend for any pet parents of pups with separation anxiety.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Thanks Zesty Paws for the free Calming Plus Bites! My dogs love the flavor of these treats and coming running when they hear the crinkling of the bag. While the flavor appears to be great, I did notice that they didn't seem to do much for my dogs by way of calming. So I deducted two stars for effectiveness. However, I realize every dog's experience may be different - so don't hesitate to give this product a try.