[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The treat made my dog very sleepy, in such a way that I would not use them for regular use. However, if there were a trip or fireworks, I would try it again. My dog ate the treat the first time, but turned his nose up every other time I offered.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I gave my 3 year old 75 lb Belgian Malinois the appropriate amount of the calming treats. She absolutely loves them. She ate each one with no issues. She rested well and wasn't running arms as she usually does.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have two large dogs. One is over 75lbs and one is over 90lbs. Not only did they both love the flavor of these claiming bites, but after following the package dosing chart and giving them each 3 bites, they were calm and chill. This may be my new favorite (and effective) dog supplement ever!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dog definitely enjoyed these, and I do think I noticed that she was calmer when I gave her the appropriate dosage from the bag. She's a ~50lb lab mix and it says you can give 2 treats per day for her size. My only complaint is that the treats are kind of messy, they're the kind of treat you want to wash your hands after feeding. They're like powdery or crumbly on the outside.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received the product for Free in exchange for my honest review. As you can see in the video, my dog Frank absolutely loves these Zesty Paws Calming Plus Bites. The soft texture and the flavor seem to be his favorite! For me, I love the calming effect that they create for him! Frank is a precocious, 2yr old, 90lb, pitbull mix, with anxiety. By giving him the recommended dosage per his weight, once a day, as needed, he becomes much more calmer in stressful situations. I will definitely be recommending this product to all of my dog-owning friends and family!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I'll admit, I had a lot of doubt that this would work. I was pleasantly surprised after I gave them to my dog, Pepper. I give these treats to her around 7pm, a time of night when she is usually off the wall because she has been home alone all day. About a half hour after I give her these treats, she is calm and relaxed! I will definitely continue to use these treats. I think they would be very useful for the times I travel and she has to be boarded.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dogs get riled up when there are new guests coming over. So I gave them a few before I had a party and they really worked! My dogs remained mellow throughout the evening. I honestly was surprised they worked!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] After a month I am finally able to give a full review. I wanted to see if these would be effective for my large breed senior dog so I tried to give her some of these calming treats ahead of time on different occasions to see if her anxiety levels were lowered by it but unfortunately her behavior didn't show any notable improvement. She did enjoy the tasty treat though and it had no side effects on her digestion like some other treats do so I will purchase this brand again just not the calming bites in particular. I have tried their probiotics before and it's a fantastic product. The dosage is just not enough for my dog maybe smaller dogs might fare better!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This product worked great for our anxious dog. She gets car sick from anxiety in the car. We gave these before a long road trip. Not only did she not throw up but she seemed to have no anxiety at all. She gobbled them right up. She seemed to really enjoy their taste. And I found they had no bad odor at all.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I gave my 17 lb dog the recommended amount of treats and didn't notice a difference in her calmness or behavior. She has a lot of energy and it seemed the same level. She did really enjoy the taste of them. I'll continue to give them to her as she liked the taste but didn't notice a calming effect as advertised.