[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] We have six dogs and these are great when we have something going on at the property to keep everyone from getting upset at the activity. Only drawback is they tend to get crumbly at the bottom of the bag so it's hard to give out pieces.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have two dogs, one is a Boston Terrier, she didn't care for these treats. It might have been the flavor. I do like that they are easy to crumble and mix in her food. My Pitbull enjoyed these treats.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have been giving my 60lb dog 2 of these treats each evening and I have definitely noticed a calming effect where she is normally extremely hyper. I don't think it would be strong enough to keep her calm during fireworks or other stressful events but they do help her relax in general. My dog also thinks they taste great and is excited for them each night so that is a bonus!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have two dogs one little guy and a big one and the big one is hard to get to calm down hence my excitement to try these! They both have been getting them regularly before we need to step out and leave them at home for a few hours and Im very happy with how they are working. The boys are mellow and calm without being "high" or drugged if you know what I mean. They are natural and do exactly what they are supposed to supposed to! Will definitely repurchase. I only took off a star because of the flavor being chicken which upsets my Goldens stomach a little!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Our boy Jackson is a mini golden doodle and a ball of energy. I give him 2 of these (per his weight and package recommendations) and he chilllllllssss out. It's so nice for if we have people coming over or taking a road trip. These are amazing and easy on his tummy and he loves them.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I gave to my dogs the day before and morning of us leaving for vacation. It only seemed to work for about an hour. They get very frantic when seeing our bags packed and us loading up the car. They were just as frantic as usual which is a bummer. I will continue to have to look for something else that will work.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My golden gets too excited when seeing a new person come to the house. He has to be in their face and start jumping on them. I thought because he's older he would stop but he hasn't so I've tried many calming treats. These work the best. He's still a little excited but nothing like he is without them. Sometimes he's so relaxed he will go to sleep.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Here's the thing, this could be one of those "my dog" things, and not the product itself. We tried them 3 different times. She did not slow her roll, and almost was more anxious. It was strange. I plan to try them again, in a few weeks. She may have just been having an off week. She's typically not super hyper but some weather related noises made her a bit skiddish, and these came in so I figured perfect timing. Using them 3 times I had hoped they'd help her out a bit. Overall mostly the same. With that being said, for another dog these may work just fine and I wouldn't deter someone- in fact I'd want to know if my friends dogs did well with them and if they were chill :) Pros: soft and chewy, not that gross dog treat smell

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I own a Belgian Malinois, which is probably one of the most high strung breeds on the face of the earth, to say that I was skeptical is an understatement. I have been giving these treats to my good boy for 2 weeks, I thought surely there was no way that 2 tiny little treats would have any effect on him whatsoever. I have been pleasantly surprised! 2 treats and he will stop his normal chaos and chill for a bit. The treats don't knock him out, just seems to level him out for a bit. *I received a sample of this product free of charge for an honest review.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I was excited for my dog to try the Zesty Paws Calming Plus Bites and was really hoping these treats would help to ease his anxiety and make him relax, but while they did seem to take the edge off, they also upset his stomach and caused some digestive issues shortly after eating them. A couple hours after his first dose, he had some diarrhea, vomiting and overall looked clearly uncomfortable. I gave it another shot the next day with only half a dose this time, but unfortunately the tummy issues still persisted. I like the concept and the wholesome all natural ingredients seem thoughtfully chosen but if your pup has a sensitive stomach like mine, you might want to try something else. Every dog is different though, so if yours has a more ironclad stomach, they might work great but I recommend starting with smaller doses first just to see how they react.