The kibble is too hard for dogs to digest. I tried soaking it in water. After 2 hours, it still was hard. My dog refused to eat it after a couple of days and was acting weak. I think the food cannot break down and is unable to provide the nutrients needed to support the dog's nutritional needs.

I've been using this brand for many years for my Golden Retreivers and suddenly they change the packaging. Unbeknownst to me (I wasn't thinking it was even a possibility) the new packaging does not have a closable tab. I was disappointed, since it keeps the food so much fresher and helps me due to arthritis, but figured, when in Rome... When I cut the top open and spread the opening to dip out a serving, the bag ripped down the side and my guy thought he had died and gone to heaven. Dog food ALL OVER THE FLOOR!!. I wound up taking the old bag from the garbage and transferring the new contents to the previously used bag (WHICH WAS A FEAT IN ITSELF). If I can no longer get the old-type packaging, I will have to switch to another store to buy his food. As it is, I have to travel 50 miles one way for supplies once a month so buying somewhere closer really makes a whole lot more sense. PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE BRING BACK THE BAGS WITH THE ZIPPER-STYLE CLOSURE!!

For the second consecutive week I attempted to buy Members Mark dog food (Lamb and Brown Rice) but it was out of stock. This is probably the 4th or 5th time this year this product has been out of stock. There are no locations within 150 miles of my location that have this. I am not going to continue to change my dogs diet due to your constant stocking issues. I buy 2 bags of this product every couple of weeks and it is one of the main products that I keep my membership for. I am going to let my membership expire if this issue is not corrected before I am due to renew my membership. I am also tired of there being more associates at the exit checking receipts than there are actual cashiers. Shopping at your stores is no longer a pleasure and definitely not worth paying annual dues for.

My dog loves this food, thrives on it. HOWEVER, the bag it's packaged in is TRULY awful, CAN'T be re-sealed like the previous packaging. Packaging is SO bad, it knocks my review down from 5 stars overall to ONE star overall, and a "do not recommend". The previous bag had zip seal closure on it to keep it fresh, NOT possible to re-seal this bag. I'll have to figure out some alternate storage to keep it from getting stale. How much could POSSIBLY been saved by eliminating the zip sea? Fifty cents, MAYBE? I'd rather pay the extra few cents for a bag that's actually USEABLE.

I have never seen my pup react this way to a dog food. When the package arrived, he just stared at it. Opening the package he was ecstatic. He then guarded the bag. I used to be able to fill his bowl and he would nibble through the day. He scarfs this bowl.

I was amazed to see a kibble that checked all the boxes.. real meat, not just meal, as the first ingredient; taurine for heart health (very hard to find), fatty acids from salmon and supplements for joints and digestion. But .... my golden is not interested in it. Will walk away and not eat until we add something. I love this formula so much that for now, we will oblige him but it's sad they can't make it more palatable (even with "natural flavor" (lol) added . Good value for a quality formula .. but be prepared to add a little something to get them to eat it

It’s the ingredients our dogs need at the best price. Sad that its on recall

My dog Is still getting used to it.

Our dogs love this food and seem to be so much more satisfied!

I chose this for my dog’s allergies.