I had to buy this dog food and a pinch because Sam’s was out out of our regular salmon grain free dog food. While this particular type of food did not work out for us Sam’s did an amazing job of exchanging and allowing us to get what our girlie needed.

My 2yo dog (Belgian Malinois) has always had soft stool and skin allergies. I've always mixed dry and wet food for him. His previous food were Purina Pro Plan and Iam's for dry with Farmers Dog and Purina Pro Plan for wet. I've also previously tried Orijen and Acana premium brands. All basically same result. With rising prices, I decided to look at some more economical options. My vet has insisted to avoid grain-free foods due to studies pointing to heart issues. So I did some exploration and found that Dogfoodadvisor.com gave the Members Mark brand a very high score of 5 stars (highly recommend). I reviewed their analysis and details to find that the food appears to be high quality consist with other premium brands. And the cost was dramatically less at Sam's Club. So I decided to give it a try. First, my dog seems to love this food (more than others). He's not super picky but he wastes no time with devouring this food. Second, an unexpected benefit has been that he now has had consistent well-formed stools every day. His stool also seems to smell less. His allergies have also subsided but this may be attributed to the changing of the season and allergy levels rather than food. I'll have a better gauge after a year. Overall, I'm really happy that this food appears to be high quality, affordable, healthy and delicious to my dog. I have to admit that I was very hesitant initially. I am extremely picky about food and treats for my dogs and their countries of origin. And honestly, my perception is that Walmart/Sam's make their products with the absolute lowest cost (and thereby lowest quality) to offer a cheap option. So far, this food has started to shift my perspective. I hope that this food continues to perform well and no issues or concerns. I have a feeling my vet may take issue with this brand but we'll see at my dog's next annual exam in the Fall. So far.. it's been surprisingly good.

Changed my dogs food to this when one of my Dauchsands starting rejecting the Members Mark Salmon. Mixed the lamb with Salmon until just lamb. None of my five dogs had a problem with the change and are doing great with it. I love the size of it with my small dogs.

The only thing Henry Pup loves more than me is FOOD, and he's enjoying his Maker's Mark Lamb and Brown Rice Recipe kibble, which he will more than nibble unless I encourage him to take his time.

I have bought the Members Mark brand food for my pups a couple of times now, have tried other brands of dog food before. But I will definitely be buying this food for my pups more often now! because they really seem to like it, also with seasonal allergies, I believe they don't itch as much when eating the Brown Rice and Lamb.

Our dogs liked it at first, but then we got a bag that smelled terrible. The dogs wouldn’t touch it. We switched to a different brand and haven’t had an issue since. Not sure what happened but wasn’t good.

The ingredients and kibble appeared fine, but my dog did not like it. She's not a picky eater but she would not eat this lol The rare times she ate a bit of it, she did not have a reaction, so it's probably good if your dog will eat it.

I have been buying this brand for a long time and it is sometimes out of stock without any notice. It seems to be a decent food and my dogs like it. I have six dogs of different breeds. Unfortunately this bag had some type of moldy substance in it so I had to return it. This is the only time this is ever happened But now I am watching the Food more closely.

Sorry our dog didnt like it and didnt want to eat or had to force it down because she was hungry. Then she would have the runs no regular hard poop. Had to switch to something else. Wish Sams would have diffrent tÿps of dog and cat food not alot but more options

The dog food had some unidentified white stuff on parts of it and those groups were stuck to the inside of the bag. I had fed my dogs with the food until I noticed the white stuff and my three dogs were having diarrhea. I bought another bag and it seemed ok and my dogs diarrhea stopped. I called Sam's and talked with a person who was obviously from another country and I got a $12 gift card for my troubles. What about the bad bag? I've got to take it to Sam's to get a refund. I'm not! It was delivered and if Sam's wants it back they can come get it. I getting very sorry service and products from Sam's and I will soon be quitting my membership.