They eat them but they don't love them. I have a semi picky dog who has to believe they are stealing them from another dog or have them covered in something tasty. They are chewed in 10-30 seconds. I was under the impression they were for chewing on for an hour or more.

In the picture and packaging I didn't notice if it said the Beef Sticks are soft or hard but they are super hard almost like wood hard. My doggie didn't seem to like it at first but after a while he started to break it off and eat it. This snack will be one of his last snack to go to.

These sticks are one of my dogs' favorite treats. All three of my creatures just love it when I get the bag out and open it. They know it is treat time and oh, are they excited. If a dog could show a huge smile this would be the time my three would do it. I do have a large male black retriever and he does curl his lip up, so I consider this a smile.

I have purchased this product several time now. It is very well received by my lab who seems to love them. They are also easy to break in half and give a 1/2 treat if you desire. I now go back and forth between rawhides (my dog's favorite) and these. These do not have same the chewing longevity as do rawhides if that matters to you.

My dogs loved these under another brand until they were taken off the market. I was thrilled to see someone else making them as my toy poodles go nuts over these treats. I actually break them in half so they can enjoy one in the morning and one in the evening. I bought two bags just in case they were a one time buy. They actually go in the kitchen and stare at the bag hoping they will accidentally fall on the floor!

Our dog really seems to enjoy these. They resemble a large pretzel stick and the crunch sound these make when she’s eating them is awesome. They aren’t like a rawhide stick or bully or collagen stick; no, not like any of these. They are airy and don’t last long so we don’t mind giving her one every day.

Not the beef pizzle sticks I usually buy. The packaging does not let you see the product. Product is some sort of manmade stick that breaks easily and the dogs finish them in a few bites. They get no chewing or dental benefit. I will not buy again.

These are crunchy and about 12 inches in length. My dogs love them. I have an 86lb, 40lb, 24lb, 14lb and this treat is broken in two for the bigger dogs and quarters for the little ones becuse they are a good size. They are a special treat so they don't get them every day. But they absolutely love them, and when all four are crunching down on these the noise has me laughing....i just love watching them enjoy this treat.

My fur baby is more than happy after upgrading to the quality and quantity of the Irish Rover Beef Stick Dog Treats and asks for his daily treat on schedule with excitement. I love that the treats are made with real beef at a great price for a good amount and the size is more than enough to keep us both happy and worry free, we will definitely keep these treats on our shopping list vs the previous processed bones that would state to keep him busy with included processed products.

Cooper gets excited and goes to the pantry when asked if he wants a Beef Stick. As I bring the bag out he always gives it a nose boop of approval! He loves the flavor and crunch. I love the convenient bag and the ease with breaking into pieces if you want. On our 3rd. bag! Also recommended to friends!