These are okay. I expected them to last longer, but my dog eats the whole thing in 5 seconds because its brittle. I worry she will choke or hurt herself with swallowing a sharp piece. I bought these because they were a slightly better deal than the chew sticks I usually buy, which last her much longer. I wont be buying again.

Not the beef pizzle sticks I usually buy. The packaging does not let you see the product. Product is some sort of manmade stick that breaks easily and the dogs finish them in a few bites. They get no chewing or dental benefit. I will not buy again.

They eat them but they don't love them. I have a semi picky dog who has to believe they are stealing them from another dog or have them covered in something tasty. They are chewed in 10-30 seconds. I was under the impression they were for chewing on for an hour or more.

I have purchased this product several time now. It is very well received by my lab who seems to love them. They are also easy to break in half and give a 1/2 treat if you desire. I now go back and forth between rawhides (my dog's favorite) and these. These do not have same the chewing longevity as do rawhides if that matters to you.

Great product for a great price!! My dogs LOVE them!!

My five pups are always happy to get the beef snack sticks.

My Dane and Yorkie love them

Half the dogs don’t like them, and they are messy

Fabulous crunchy treat that can be easily broken into pieces for smaller dogs

Made my dog horribly sick. She was vomiting and had diarrhea all night long.