We have five dogs, all over seventy pounds. Every morning they dance when it's "crunchy time", from the two-year-old Black Lab to the fourteen-year-old Golden Retriever. They all sit very pretty to receive it, then run to their personal eating space. It is a very loud and happy time in the mornings at our house.

My dogs love them....I am so glad to purchase a product that is exactly what it says it is....Beef Sticks......made with Beef!

All 4 of our girls love these all beef treats, and they get them every day! Just be careful giving them to old dogs or puppies, they might choke-- they're too hard for our 16 year old guy and they easily break into chokable pieces for the too young or old.

My dog loves these, but I love them too because there is only one ingredient in it, beef. No additives.

I love this product! Of course I don’t eat them though. My dogs are warming up to them. The first night I gave them one niether one would eat it. Now they are excited to get them!

Our dog loves these! They are not like regular bully sticks--they are quickly eaten and very crunchy--and a bit messy. Easy to break into pieces (literally) and dogs LOVE them! They are NOT solid and dont last a long time like regular bully sticks--more like a quick snack that can be eaten very quickly

We used to buy these a few years ago and the dogs loved them. We called them “crunchy crunches” and they would get excited when they heard me say it. We moved and our new Sams didn’t carry them till just recently. I was excited to see them again and bought 2 bags. When I went to break it in half , there was no familiar crunch sound , it was soft and bendy, almost stale. The outer layer was super thin and they filled the middle with some kind of soft filling. It was really an entirely new treat altogether. They ate it but not with the same excitement. Like they cheapened the recipe. Not surprised tho as this seems to happen these days with most things that are good. Sadly I won’t be buying these again for my dogs. Also I usually only buy treats that are made in the USA and these are made in Ireland. Possibly another change but I am not certain on that. Anyway , just disappointed.

A bit dry and crispy. Reminded me of bark. It needed some meat in it. I won’t be buying it again.

Our dogs didn’t like these, they’re crunchy and turned into crumbs all over the floor. We gave the bag away and warned the people to feed the treats outside.

Extremely hard and not chewy at all. I had to soak it in water to make it easier for the dog to chew