My dog loved them will be purchasing them again.

Our dog loves these! They are not like regular bully sticks--they are quickly eaten and very crunchy--and a bit messy. Easy to break into pieces (literally) and dogs LOVE them! They are NOT solid and dont last a long time like regular bully sticks--more like a quick snack that can be eaten very quickly

The girls love these! The plus is they are big enough that they can share one treat. They come running when they hear the bag open.

Dogs love them

My dogs live these!

In the picture and packaging I didn't notice if it said the Beef Sticks are soft or hard but they are super hard almost like wood hard. My doggie didn't seem to like it at first but after a while he started to break it off and eat it. This snack will be one of his last snack to go to.

Excellent product glad to see it back

Dogs enjoy the savory beef sticks every time.

My dog loves these stinky treats.