Not the beef pizzle sticks I usually buy. The packaging does not let you see the product. Product is some sort of manmade stick that breaks easily and the dogs finish them in a few bites. They get no chewing or dental benefit. I will not buy again.

Our dog really seems to enjoy these. They resemble a large pretzel stick and the crunch sound these make when she’s eating them is awesome. They aren’t like a rawhide stick or bully or collagen stick; no, not like any of these. They are airy and don’t last long so we don’t mind giving her one every day.

Cooper gets excited and goes to the pantry when asked if he wants a Beef Stick. As I bring the bag out he always gives it a nose boop of approval! He loves the flavor and crunch. I love the convenient bag and the ease with breaking into pieces if you want. On our 3rd. bag! Also recommended to friends!

These sticks are one of my dogs' favorite treats. All three of my creatures just love it when I get the bag out and open it. They know it is treat time and oh, are they excited. If a dog could show a huge smile this would be the time my three would do it. I do have a large male black retriever and he does curl his lip up, so I consider this a smile.

My dog, a Vizsla, does not like these. I don't know if it's the way they taste or the way they crumble into little pieces. I learned from the very first one that this was an outside treat and not for inside—what a mess with little crumbs all aver the carpet.

My boys love these. They're very crunchy! I break them up and give them pieces and not the whole stick at a time. Some are easier to break by hand than others and there seems to be two different kinds of sticks in the bag- a reddish one and a brown one with spots that i assume is fat) Not sure if it's supposed to be or not since the pic on the bag only pictures the red one. I tried to upload a photo of the two different sticks but i keep getting an operation couldn't be completed error.

DO NOT BUY THIS PRODUCT! We were excited to see a new product when at our local sams club for our furbaby and immediately grabbed it. We gave it to her later that evening for her daily treat and within a few hours, she was horribly sick. We ended up having to take her to the ER vet two days later as she had a lower GI infection. Since she had not ingested anything during that period (she was so sick she couldn't eat) this product was the cause of the infection. She is on antibiotics still and will be for 10 days. It cost alot of money and she could have been really bad if we didn't catch it. DO NOT BUY THIS PRODUCT!!!

My dog looks forward to her treats just like any other dog, but these treats right here are like tree bark. They are so dry, zero to no moisture whatsoever, and hard, Despite the smell, my dog treated it like it was a stick. She would not eat it, she brought it to my feet to play fetch instead of enjoying the treat. For us it was a big NO.

Our dogs like them.

The dogs love these!