New recipe is awful! I thought the chicken salad looked different but bought it anyway. When I got home and opened it, there were oily spots on the top and bottom. I will probably throw it away! The old recipe was my favorite. Very disappointed in the chicken salad now!

First time buying and trying this, and let me tell you, this was the worst chicken salad I've had. It was extremely salty, and the chicken tasted like canned chicken with a texture similar to canned tuna. I'm really disappointed. It's called “rotisserie chicken salad,” but nothing about it tasted like rotisserie chicken. I expected fresh flavor and real shredded chicken, but instead it tasted overly processed. I could barely finish a few bites before throwing it away. For the price I expected something tasty. Unfortunately, I would not purchase this again or recommend it.

I had been buying this chicken salad weekly and it was so good but recently the recipe changed and it is terrible now. I had to throw 2 full containers of it away because I thought the first one was a fluke. Nope…I believe they have added sweet pickle relish to it and ruined it.

i ordered this chicken salad for delivery and instantly noticed a different appearance of the product. i would have returned it if i had the time. We did eat about half of it, but was disappointed in the taste %26 mushy texture. please bring back the original recipe- it was one of our must buys, now it's a pass.

I received a free sample for my honest review. What's better than Sam's Club rotisserie chicken? Sam's Club rotisserie chicken that has already been made into chicken salad. this tastes like you made it with all the fresh ingredients you would use if you had time. The flavor is excellent, but neutral enough that you can add in extras like walnuts and craisins if that's how you like your chicken salad.

Why why why??? Y'all changed my the recipe for my favorite item. I thought I was eating tuna salad for a second when eating it. Usually eat half a pack for a meal, couldn't even go past 3 bites. Not gonna be picking it till the other chicken salad is back

It's not consistent. I want to like it but not fully on board. Either too much mayo at times , or too much salt. I do like the consistency and think it could be really good if the batch-consistency gets better. After 4 purchases I probably will not try again any time soon.

The Sam's club rotisserie chicken salad used to be a go to favorite, but I don't like the new recipe. The switch from celery to sweet relish and shredded chicken ruined the former delicious chicken salad. There's no redeeming it. I won't buy it again unless Sam's brings back the original recipe. Please bring back the original recipe.

why change the recipe??? i have bought chicken salad from the Oxford, AL location for years. i am extremely disappointed in the recipe change. it was once large chunks of white meat chicken, mayo, and celery but now it is grey chicken mush with too many seasonings. paprika does not belong in chicken salad. i really hope the old recipe returns quickly. i can see by the latest 1 star reviews i'm not the only dissatisfied customer.

Horrible!!! Did the recipe change???? This Chicken Salad has been a staple in my house for a long time, but this last purchase was DISGUSTING!!!! So bad that I checked the expiration date three times to see if it had expired. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE go back to the original recipe!!!