Both sides cook different on the same setting. The setting handles are not the same either. They're spring loaded and one pushes down easy the other hard. I'm returning.

I love this toaster! Each side is individually temperature controlled and can use one side at a time. You can cancel it if the toast color is how you like it. And it has an alarm when the toast pops up!

Works fine as long as you check the browness level every use or you get burned toast. The dial moves easily and there’s no marking on it just an indentation for where to set it on the numbers

Great toaster. Centers narrow bread slices for even toasting while being able to evenly toast wide slices and bagels as well. Looks great on the counter too, matching the other counter top appliances nicely.

Can't get a better toaster at a better price than Sam's. The last one we had actually melt down when our house was on fire. We had to get the same toaster!

The “shade” numbers are misleading the lowest setting still toasts the toast a lot (more than I typically like). I would hate to see what setting two through 5 are. Probably ash. If you or your kids like lightly toasted bread look elsewhere

Nice retro design and practical functions, I needed it fro my bagels and love the red accent color with the stainless steal body. Easy to use and hopefully cleaning as well :-)

really disappointed with this toaster . no matter what setting you pick . it's always darker on one side of the toast. walmart would not take bake because original box got throw away .

Toasts evenly and I like the bagel option. To get the 5th star, they need to increase the lift spring tension so the toast stays all the way up when done.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The toaster does not light up when toasting and it is very slow to get it to the toast level you want.