My black Labrador had bad diareah with Buffalo dog food. I thought it was due to his cancer but I decided to change it to this one and finally he's pooping great. I'm so happy he's feeling better. No more crying and accidents

The formula certainly changed. The food doesn't smell as fishy as when we first started buying it; my GS is proof, she no longer gobbles her food down. It sometimes takes 2 days to complete her meal. Might be forced to switch!

My dogs never liked this since I started buying it a year ago. Now in the last 6 months they have all died from liver/heart problems. An enlarged heart on all 3 dogs who had been healthy is not just a coincidence!

Love the value of this dog food and it gives my Rott's coat a lot of shine. Been using for years but now it gives my dog such terrible gas that I have to switch.

I feed my dogs grain free dog food and was interested in Member's Mark. But in it are dried peas, pea protein, nonspecified animal fat and especially menadione. All of which are arguably not high quality items. This is disappointing. I am also not crazy about "natural flavor" whatever that is. Member's Mark needs to eliminate these items before it can be considered a quality dog food.

My English Bulldog has been on Purina pro plan salmon and rice for 2 years and I decided to try to save some money and get this. He refused to eat it. He went 4 days without eating till I went and bought his old food and he ate again. I had thrown the bad away or I most definitely would have returned this.

This product works for a little while then it gets stale. Because the packaging does not work. It has a high end zipper on the package and it has never been reliable. After about 2 weeks it breaks then the smell of salmon fills the pantry, YUCK, and the food gets stale. After experiencing this for a couple years it's time to shop elsewhere.

This food caused my dog to develop diet associated congestive heart failure and he recently passed. I would strongly suggest speaking to your vet about the risks associated with a grain free diet before feeding your dog this food. It could save their life.

This food smells like a fishing dock, and my dog would not go anywhere near it. I had mixed some of his soft food into the dry food so he'd eat some… he threw it all up. Brown liquid everywhere. He also had diarrhea for almost three days. Returned it immediately.

Exceed Salmon & Peas Grain Free is probably the best dog food sold by Sam's Club. That said, Dog Food Advisor gave it only 3.5 stars out of 5 and my dogs simply did not like it. I have since gone to a more premium product, Canidae Grain Free Pure Elements, which gets Dog Food Advisor's highest rating. To properly transition from Exceed to Canidae, I am mixing the two kibbles together. Unfortunately, my dogs like the Canidae product so much, they are pick-out the Exceed kibble and leave it all over the floor while only eating the Canidae kibble. Sometimes it's worthwhile to pay a little more.