We USED to use this cat litter all the time. The formula was recently changed and now it is the WORST cat litter I have ever used in over 40 yrs of owning cats. It has a high amount of dust and very tiny black charcoal pieces that our cats track all over the house. I have never seen such a horrible mess!! The charcoal adds nothing, it smells worse than ever. I suggest it's just in there as useless filler. Unless they return it back to it's original formula we will never purchase this terrible product again.

Absolutely the worst dusty litter I have ever used. It has made an absolute mess out of my utility room with dust on everything. I normally have a vacuum running above the litter box to suck up normal dust when I refill the litter box due to volume being generated but with this stuff I am surrounded in a cloud of dust just from scooping waste from the box twice a day. Would have given it negative overall rating if it was possible.

I've been using this when money gets tight. I prefer the fresh step but it's $34.00 for two 42lb bags, where this is $21.00 for the same. So when money is tight it's a no brainer. however, the caveat has always been that this stuff is like a dust bomb. it coats EVERYTHING in the room it's in with dust. not just a little, a lot. I bought two tubs again last month and when i went to pour it in, i was pleasantly surprised that there was suddenly almost zero dust! I couldn't believe it! Got to the second tub a month later and the same thing! I thought i must have gotten lucky and got a good batch, but I went in to get more last week, and when i opened the new one, it's the same thing! Somewhere down the line they made a change and the one thing that I hated about this otherwise best choice, is now fixed and IMO this is a fantastic choice! From now on I won't be buying this when money is tight, I'm going to get it all the time because it's great! Thank you!

This used to have a sent kind of like lemon grass, now it smells like any other litter. Not only do I have multiple chemical sensitivities but the cats refuse to use litter with a strong scent. I was going to get a Sam's Club membership but canceled when I found out I couldn't get the same litter.

Today marks the one year anniversary of the call from our vet saying that our cat Sassys condition was grave. Perfectly healthy indoor cat that faithfully used our litter box which unfortunately had the Members Mark cat litter from Sam's. Her eyes became crusted and her nose. Her paws were caked with cat litter. It was so bad that our other cats started peeing on the floor and we blamed our dog till we saw the other cats do it (but they were inside / outside cats so they were doing their best to get outside. At first the Vet thought it was an allergy till we told them the only thing that was different was the litter. We always use Tidy Cats mainly Lightweight but Sams was out so I bought Members Mark (I regret that to this day). Reported it to Sam's got a case number and was turned over to someone that represented the manufacturer Noramerica to no avail (sad). The biggest damage is the loss of our family cat Sassy which is far more than the material or Veterinarian bill. One more note this was so dusty it was everywhere and I have a husband with COPD which could have been devastating. Will try to attach photos of Sassy before and after the Members Mark cat litter. But if there was a no star that would be our choice.

This is great litter for the price. Can you get better? Sure, but it makes no sense to pay double for a little better clumping. If you keep too little litter in the box, it does tend to not clump as good. But cats don't like that either. Just put a reasonable amount of litter in the box and it clumps fine. An inch or more is good. Your cat will thank you. The scent on this is not overbearing. I usually buy unscented litter but this is fine. Not too dusty either. Nice reusable bucket as well, I hate to throw them out. I keep a few empties and give the others to friends. Old men can't resist a good bucket.

My cats LOVED the lemongrass and it hardly had any dust. The new stuff is light colored clay pebbles and TONS of DUST! YUCK!!!! Wasted money! I would like a refund but will just quit buying from Sam's and not renew. Not happy. Should've disclosed the formula change. Packaging is exactly the same. Sam's is proving untrustworthy with shady quality.

I switched to this after using scoop away. I was never fully satisfied with scoop away but I found it to be the best after trying every other major brand. My husband suggested this litter and I'll admit, I was reluctant to try it but it exceeded my expectations. It clumps very tightly and hardly crumbles. It gets a dusty when you refill it, but it doesn't bother me. I'm not spending $12 every week on litter anymore. I spend $10 on this and it lasts my 4 cats a month. This is all I buy now.

Does not clump well at all. Does not contain odors well at all. Much of the urine stays in the litter after sifting, which makes the litter retain a very unpleasant aroma which eventually spreads throughout the house. On top of this, it is VERY dusty. An actual cloud forms when sifting the litter. I switched back to Fresh Step, and all is much better now. Due to the better clumping of Fresh Step, it takes much longer to go through a bucket of litter, making the Fresh Step actually cheaper in the long run.

I needed kitty litter, and my Sam's was out of my usual Fresh Step, so I bought a bucket of this. Odor control seems OK, not sure about the dust because that's not really a factor for me, but scoopability is poor, at best. The Fresh Step litter holds the clumps much better than this product. Every time I scoop (every day and sometimes 2X/day) some of the clumps break up and are redistributed into the "clean" litter, and are too small to pick up with my scooper. I am quite disappointed in my purchase. I know I can return it, but I'll probably keep this bucket since I only bought the one. If my Sam's is out of Fresh Step the next time, I'll either order it online or buy it elsewhere.