We buy this litter because we have four finicky cats that hate clay litter and it's a 40lb bucket for less than $10. We usually get two buckets a month. Yes, it can be dusty- especially when pouring into the pan. But I haven't had an issue with the dust after that with either of my two pans on carpet or the two on bare floor. The odor control/clumping isn't anything super disappointing to me as well, but with whatever brand of litter I have on hand I always add probably a cup of baking soda to each new litter change out and sprinkle in a couple of tablespoons after every scooping as well. I just grab a 3lb bag of baking soda from the baking aisle when we're there. The bag lasts us like six weeks and costs less than four bucks. All in all, still a great value for us.

We bought the Member's Mark clumping litter because our warehouse was out of our Tidy Cats Lightweight at the time. This stuff is terrible! It's super dusty, doesn't clump well, is very heavy and I find myself needing to fully change out the box more often because it just doesn't scoop. Yes, it was cheaper but in this case you definitely get what you pay for. The lightweight stuff might be twice the price but it lasts 2-3 times as long...easily.

I love the clumping and deodering part, it gets the job done well for the price. But it's so dusty!!! My automatic air purifier would work so hard every time I add litter to fill up littler box, or even after my cats goes in and out if the litter box!!! And I think I can feel I inhaled some while playing w my cats... I would pay more to have my cat litter dust free/low dust.

This litter is the worst! I clean our barn kitten's litterbox every day or every other and it turns urine into a giant clump that gets stuck to the bottom of the litterbox. I initially thought water got in the easy clean box so I changed out the litter completely and it happened again. It gets so clumped that our kitten can't even dig around to do her business. I have tried multiple different cat litter, being a new cat owner, and none of them have done this. I will not purchase this again! Just spend the extra money on a name brand.

Dislike giving negative reviews. Everybody uses products differently so outcomes can vary. This is my personal experience. Recrived tree pails of this kitty litter last week. Have two cats and three litter boxes. Washed out our three litter boxes and filled with fresh. Always scoop once a day and now twice most days. Litter does clump; however, most are clumps of mud-like balls. Unsure what it would take for the clumps to dryout as with other litters. Little to no odor control as I can smell litter boxes when opening the front door. Although price was good (discounted at time of order), savings not worth the frustration. Haven't actually looked at bucket to see if there''s a satisfaction guarantee. Regardless, wouldn't want three more buckets. Maybe more expensive but many of the name brands do a much better job based on this recent experience.

I bought it because of the price. You can't beat it! And then I read the reviews and thought “oh no, I made a mistake”. But to my surprise I actually like it. It's not dusty at all it's a lot of litter for the price....and it clumps like it's suppose to...The only thing that l don't like is that it doesn't do much for the smell...So I find myself changing the litter often, because just scooping isn't enough, the smell lingers...

I have been using this litter for years and it was just as good as Tidy Cats clumping litter. The last container that I purchased no longer clumps. It's in the exact same container, but the quality is terrible. I guess Sam's decided to change vendors. I will no longer be purchasing this litter.

This used to be a great cat litter but the last couple of times I've been disappointed. I've been using this cat litter for over a year and it's just not the same quality as it used to be. The clumps don't stick together when you scoop. If you want a clumping cat litter then look elsewhere.

I've never reviewed cat litter because they all have been within the same range of quality in my mind. This IS NOT! It is horribly dusty when you pour out, creates an actual cloud in my laundry room where I have 2 boxes in a good size room. There is also zero scent control! I scoop litter nightly and replace completely every Friday and my laundry room stinks every time I walk in. My cats seem to soak it daily to where I can barely scoop at all....so glad the bucket is empty!!! I wouldn't recommend to anyone...even people that drive me nuts...it's just so bad!

We started using this litter again & it is so dusty. The whole house is filled with dust. I hate to know what it's doing to the cat's lungs & our human lungs. I have two containers to take back to the store for a refund. It's a nice price but not worth the dust.