Have been using this liter for about a year now and it NO longer clumps. It's an absolute disaster. On top of that, this litter is actually a health hazard for you and your cats because of the large amount of dust. I've had cats for over 30 years and by far this is the absolute worst litter I have ever used.

If you want a no tracking and tight clumping cat litter then this is your best choice. The litter clumps so tight I needed to purchase a heavy gage scooper to pick up everything. I have 2 cats and have tried every type, brand and price. My club was sold out so we “settled” for a named brand from the pet store and I now have tiny granules on the floor. Best litter and at a great price.

Now it is a little dusty, but. Clumps the best I have ever tried. I use less little because of this. No Particles and pieces sifting through the scooper. The cats like it. I was using about 3 Tidy Cat (35lb tubs) per month. With this, I use about one and a half. Can't beat that and the price just saves me a ton of cash. $15 a month as opposed to $42. So it's your choice. Oh and no odors either.

This litter is so so dusty. Only use if you don't plan on using the room for anything else because everything will be covered in dust. Also, be warned that cleaning the litter box creates a dust everywhere and it's hard not to breath it and it's disgusting.

This litter has always been my go-to litter for a 2 cat household with 2 litter boxes. Something has changed. The litter is so very dusty I need to cover my face when cleaning the box. The dust is that bad. The room where the litter boxes are located is covered in dust every day and the dust is not like just regular dust, but requires dusting and then wiping down with water to get it all up. I don't know what has happened with this member's mark brand, but something is not the same.

Does not clump well at all. Does not contain odors well at all. Much of the urine stays in the litter after sifting, which makes the litter retain a very unpleasant aroma which eventually spreads throughout the house. On top of this, it is VERY dusty. An actual cloud forms when sifting the litter. I switched back to Fresh Step, and all is much better now. Due to the better clumping of Fresh Step, it takes much longer to go through a bucket of litter, making the Fresh Step actually cheaper in the long run.

This product is terrible! I bought it instead of the Fresh Step I normally buy, hoping to save money, and I was so sorry! Bought two containers, and used one and threw out the other. Smells within a day of use, does not clump well, if at all. Save the hassle and buy the Fresh Step: it blocks odors, clumps tightly, and lasts longer.

This used to be a great cat litter but the last couple of times I've been disappointed. I've been using this cat litter for over a year and it's just not the same quality as it used to be. The clumps don't stick together when you scoop. If you want a clumping cat litter then look elsewhere.

I am livid with Member's Mark for their most recent change with this cat litter (Item #457060 bought on 11-30-18) and I think I figured out Member's Mark little trick...2 years ago many reviewers wrote about the change of litter, specifically stating "New Improved 4-in-1 Formula", I have been buying this litter probably for a good 2 years and I have always been pleased with it until my last purchase which was on 11-30-18! I cannot get over the amount of dust my entire room that the enclosed litter box is kept in and how much dust just clouds out as you pour fresh from the bucket into the litter but also just the amount of dust that bellows out while scooping the box. I am not being dramatic, I feel like I need a shower after scooping a few pieces of poo and a couple of urine clumps (which stays clumped for the most part IF you get right under it, hit it off to the side or shake excess good litter off your scooper too much, it falls apart!). My theory is they have kept the same label "New Improved Formula" for the entire past two years and then they can switch that litter ingredients as much as they want to! I was going to put in here to save your money and just go buy some Tidy Cat if you don't care about the dust but I see (conveniently) Sam's Club sells Tidy Cat and we all know how store name brands work. This has been horrible and I would have been much farther ahead buying a Top Brand Name Litter when you consider the amount of polish and rags and vacuuming I had to do. To Member's Mark = I didn't buy Tidy Cat!!!

Love this cat litter