Here are the pros concerning this product: solid waste is 'encapsulated' in the product and odor is blocked totally; urine clumps together completely and, when scooped out, leaves no particles or residual odor in the box; the product lasts longer than competing brands because you never have to completely empty the box; the price is considerably less than any other product The cons of this product: it is dustier than any other product I have ever used; it is the heaviest product I have ever used with the exception of clay non-clumping litter

I BOUGHT THIS ABOUT 3 WEEKS AGO,IT WAS CHEAPER BUT IT IS SO DUSTY TO SCOOP. HAVE THIS DUST FILM ON EVERYTHING IN AREA. I COUGH ALOT AFTER SCOOPING. I DON'T THINK THIS IS ALL THAT HEALTHY FOR ME OR MY CAT. I DO NOT LIKE HOW IT CLUMP EITHER. SEEMS ALWAYS KINDA WET LOOKING. NO BETTER THAN TRADITIONAL CLAY CAT LITTER. I WILL NOT BUY AGAIN. I WILL GO BACK TO TIDY CAT FOR SURE.

Hate this cat litter, waste of money! Doesnt clump at all so the urine clumps fall apart and stink up the cat box. It does nothing to help the smell, if anything it makes it worse. The ammonia stench is so bad it burns when trying to clean the box. Had to dump the whole box and wash it out so the cats would use it again. Completely garbage cat litter, you get what you pay for and it's still a rip off.

Does not absorb smell AT ALL!!! Clumping was fine, but even after cleaning the litter box it reaked still (I was having to clean it after every use of the box )! Had to dump the litter and put in a different brand cat litter and no problems since. Will never buy again! Does Sam's accept returns because I have two more containers that need to go back!

This cat litter provides NO odor control. As a matter of fact, even after removing the clumps each day, the "clean" remainder smells awful. This remainder contains small clumps of litter that are the result of incomplete clumping. The dust factor is medium high as evidenced even before purchasing the product as every lid is covered in dust. That same dust will be in your environment upon use. This product is useful ONLY due to some kind of emergency. On my income I could really use a litter that costs less than $10 for 42 pounds as this one does. But if I have to purchase it every 4 to 5 days because of inferior quality (no odor control, low clumping capability, lots of dust)

I will continue buying this product because it clumps well. I do not like how much dust is produced when dumping our roll-over Omega litter box or when we add a scoop at a time. I would recommend service your boxes outside to avoid the dust or... what I now do is run the Dyson vacuum to suck up the airborne particulate.

I've used this before and been disappointed, but still bought again due to its price point. Never again. I would not be surprised if within 15 years, we see commercials asking "Have you ever used Sam's club kitty litter and been diagnosed with cancer? You may be entitled to compensation!" Out of all the brands I've tried, this is the dustiest. Like, hold your breath and leave the room after pouring into the box level dusty. It doesn't clump, it doesn't control odor, and makes ridiculous dust clouds every time you scoop. Don't let your thriftiness deceive you into this product, spend the extra few bucks for a better brand.

We buy this litter because we have four finicky cats that hate clay litter and it's a 40lb bucket for less than $10. We usually get two buckets a month. Yes, it can be dusty- especially when pouring into the pan. But I haven't had an issue with the dust after that with either of my two pans on carpet or the two on bare floor. The odor control/clumping isn't anything super disappointing to me as well, but with whatever brand of litter I have on hand I always add probably a cup of baking soda to each new litter change out and sprinkle in a couple of tablespoons after every scooping as well. I just grab a 3lb bag of baking soda from the baking aisle when we're there. The bag lasts us like six weeks and costs less than four bucks. All in all, still a great value for us.

We bought the Member's Mark clumping litter because our warehouse was out of our Tidy Cats Lightweight at the time. This stuff is terrible! It's super dusty, doesn't clump well, is very heavy and I find myself needing to fully change out the box more often because it just doesn't scoop. Yes, it was cheaper but in this case you definitely get what you pay for. The lightweight stuff might be twice the price but it lasts 2-3 times as long...easily.

I love the clumping and deodering part, it gets the job done well for the price. But it's so dusty!!! My automatic air purifier would work so hard every time I add litter to fill up littler box, or even after my cats goes in and out if the litter box!!! And I think I can feel I inhaled some while playing w my cats... I would pay more to have my cat litter dust free/low dust.