Bought this stuff several times because of price and good reusable bucket (great cat food bucket). However, urine clumps heavy and loose. About 25% crumbles to wet dust when scooping. Contaminates the rest with stink. Odor control is nill. Sams was out of stock last visit. So I bought a brand called Cheshire from another store. I saw the light and won't buy Member Mark again. For me better to spend a couple bucks more for the the good stuff. Cost balances out because the good stuff clumps tight and light and good odor control. Use less. I wish Member Mark would have comparable quality at good price

I was looking for my usual litter, and they didn?t have it. I bought this product, and was sorry. It is super dusty. Doesn?t clump well at all. Doesn?t contain odors well. I will not purchase or recommend this item at all. It needs to be reformulated.

It's not the best and it's not the greatest. I'm one who hates buying some my cat will just poo on so cheap is one of my priorities. It does clump and isn't super dusty. $10 is a good deal and my cat doesn't mind it, it does smell if you're not a regular cleaner.

This litter is extremely dusty. For the price and the nice, used for many things, bucket it comes in is a selling feature, but what good is that if the room the litter box is in is filled with dust, not to count that you are breathing in those fine dust particles. It's a back and forth between my husband and I, because he is stuck on the economical price, and I get that, but the dust it presents is just too much for me. I would rather pay more and not have such a dusty mess and I can't believe that all of that dust is good for cats. I have gone online to research "less dusty" litters and the number one suggested is Cat's Pride Fresh & Light Ultimate Care Premium Unscented Hypoallergenic Multi-Cat Cat Litter, which claims it is 99.9% dust free. Plan to give it a try and if it works well, hope that Sam's will some day put that in their stores.

Probably the worst cat litter I have tried. My idea of clumping litter and the manufacturer's are obviously quite different. I thought it would actually clump not just be urine soaked and stinky. The cheap turned out expensive because the only thing scoopable was the cat's #2, not what I expected. I had to completely empty the litter box rather than scoop it out so for me it was definitely not worth using at all. I had bought a second container before using it so stuck with that too.

There is so much dust the thick cloud hovers in the air for a very long time after filling the box. Also because of this the urine turns into an almost concrete consistency that's hard to scoop out. When it finally does it doesn't stay in a big clump it starts to fall apart into little pieces.

This is a terrible product that I am unable to return via the online chat or calling customer service. It is 42 pounds so difficult to bring in. I am worried that this is a dangerous product but customer service doesn't care—because of the smell that fills up the apartment even when there is a lid on it. Not only does it not clump. But it burns your eyes to be in the same room with it. And changing litter it's difficult to do and not vomit because of the litter smell. I see now why it was so cheap and the lid was on so tightly.

Hate this cat litter, waste of money! Doesnt clump at all so the urine clumps fall apart and stink up the cat box. It does nothing to help the smell, if anything it makes it worse. The ammonia stench is so bad it burns when trying to clean the box. Had to dump the whole box and wash it out so the cats would use it again. Completely garbage cat litter, you get what you pay for and it's still a rip off.

What a disappointment! I LOVE Member's Mark products! I was sad to realize once I opened the lid that I had paid for a bucket of sand! I live in the desert and could have taken my shovel outside and got the same product! I had to mix it with another cat liter just so it would not smell! Also since it is like sand it sticks to the cat paws and now you have sand all over the floor! Ugh!!! I won't be buying this on again!

I will continue buying this product because it clumps well. I do not like how much dust is produced when dumping our roll-over Omega litter box or when we add a scoop at a time. I would recommend service your boxes outside to avoid the dust or... what I now do is run the Dyson vacuum to suck up the airborne particulate.