Sadly, not the same. there's much less filling and the new pie crust is pretty horrible. I used to buy this pie every time I went to Sam's club and it was available. After last time, I do not think I will be purchasing this again unless they go back to the old crust and fill the pie properly. very very sad...

Pie has changed. Not the same as years past. Chocolate cookie base is too much. White topping is not light and fluffy. It's tuff almost dry out tasting. Very sad about this pie. I actually through it in the garbage! I've never done that to a pie ever. Sam's go back to your old recipe Don't buy

The excellent traditional crust pie they have had for years that sold great has changed to cookie crust krap that only my kids under age 10 think is decent. The filling used to be chocolatey, thick, and rich but is goopy now ewww. The traditional crust and old filling were the best please fix it back or offer both.

What was a good chocolate pie is now not fit to buy nor eat. The chocolate pie crust was crumbly, tasted like it had coconut in it and didn't go with the pie at all. This pie was over whelmingly more whipped so called topping and didn't taste good. It was not creamy, almost tough. I know that's hard to believe, but it just wasn't good. Then your taste buds finally found what was suppose to be a chocolate filling. That layer had no chocolate flavor at all. So remember the old saying, "if it ain't broke don't fix it?" This doesn't taste even close to the past years. It's broke, fix it. Such a waste of $13 but it went in the trash. That's how I fixed it.

Awful! It taste like chemicals! Why did you replace the much better and bigger French silk pie you already had?

They changed the crust from the classic crust we all loved and it made the product significantly worse

Not nearly as good as previous years. Not a fan of the chocolate crust. Been waiting forever for it to come back and was disappointed

So SAD!! The pie is ruined. The new recipe is not it. The “whip” topping was more like a cake icing. Bring back the OG recipe PLEASE

They have changed it. The French Silk pie used to have a regular pie crust, thick and rich satiny filling, with whipped topping. It tasted more like a Baker's Square pie. The new pie is nothing like it used to be. The chocolate crust tastes like dried brownie clumped together, the filling is like chocolate pudding, the whipped topping remains the same. French Silk was only available half of the year. I waited for it. I was VERY DISSAPPOINTED.

Sam's club French silk pie has always been a favorite. Reasonably priced and reminiscent of Baker's Squares version. Very excited to bring it home. THIS PIE IS NOT THE SAME. Crust is Oreo and far too sweet. The chocolate filling is barely there and most of the pie is whipped cream. So disappointed. I won't be buying this again.