December 9, 2025 - These pies have been SIGNIFICANTLY reduced in size - 'm talking about 2" I think they thought no one would notice the decrease in size, no decrease in price of course, and they put a super tall plastic dome cover on it to try to mask the shrinkage. It seems the recipe has also changed. It's not as firm of a pie as it was in the past, honestly my family is really disappointed, we all look forward to this, and it only comes out around Christmas, so you wait all year, tapping your toe for these pies to appear in the store again, only to be let down. Three stars for that, and why are they seasonal anyhow, what's seasonal about chocolate? I don't understand. In 2024 and all the other years prior we would've given five stars for this pie for a multitude of reasons, but highly disappointed in it overall this year. Please don't assume your customers are too naive to notice the size shrinkage, but not a reduction in price - oh and the big dome lid didn't work, it's still obviously a ton smaller. Fix that, because you've made it no longer a good value.

Once again a company has found a way to ruin a good thing. For years this has been the favorite holiday pie. This is the not the go to French silk pie. The chocolate tastes awful and the chocolate crust adds to the disappointment. There is a noticeable hint of a chemical aftertaste. The person who signed off on this change should be shown the door.

Delicious!

This pie was such a disappointment. I actually thew about half away. The cream topping was not good at all and we preferred the crust used last year. The previous recipe was fantastic..we bought 2 of those last year. I will not be buying any next year if rhe current version is offered.

RETURN TO THE PREVIOUS VENDER OR REICPE. THIS recipe has change NOTHING BUT A SUGER PIE. NO FLAVERING FROM THE CHOCOLATE . YUCKY

Something changed in the recipe. This pie used to be my favorite French Silk ever. But 2026 must not be their year. The chocolate tasted off, the whipped cream tasted "warm" and weird, and the crust was gummy. We threw it out. I bought 3, because I know they are seasonal. Now I will be throwing out the other two as well. Inedible.

Sam's club French silk pie has always been a favorite. Reasonably priced and reminiscent of Baker's Squares version. Very excited to bring it home. THIS PIE IS NOT THE SAME. Crust is Oreo and far too sweet. The chocolate filling is barely there and most of the pie is whipped cream. So disappointed. I won't be buying this again.

This pie is so good! I liked the old pie too but this ones chocolate crust is to die for. Another review mentioned the filling was like chocolate pudding and i think the consistency of if it similar to pudding but it's much richer and sweeter than pudding. I love this pie!

Used to be a family favorite that we purchased frequently. They made it bigger and more expensive so we stopped purchasing. Now they went back to the original size but raised the price nearly $4! The crust was changed also to a chocolate crumble crust. If they lower the cost I will purchase again. Went from $8.98 to $12.74!

Loved this pie! Perfect crust and rich chocolate filling. Will be getting this again!!