I purchased the French silk pie a few years ago and it was extremely good. Looked for it now and then to purchase again and they never seemed to have it so I was excited to see this "Chocolate Silk" pie yesterday. I thought it was the same pie. It's not. The French Silk pie had a traditional pie crust, the filling was a smooth and fluffy chocolate mousse that was almost too rich and the whipped cream topping tasted like whipped cream. This pie has a chocolate crust which is so disgusting I had to spit it out! Tasted like burnt asphalt is the only way I can describe it. So I tried the filling and topping alone and unfortunately it was not any better. Zero choclate flavor. Bizarre gummy almost slimy texture. No doubt that there is no real food in this chemical mess they're trying to pass off as a pie.

I was hoping the filling had a mousse-type filling. The filling was more of a pudding filling. The whip topping has a funny taste. Definitely not a replacement for Marie Calendar's. Not the worst I've had. I still ate the whole pie, but won't buy again.

Sadly, not the same. there's much less filling and the new pie crust is pretty horrible. I used to buy this pie every time I went to Sam's club and it was available. After last time, I do not think I will be purchasing this again unless they go back to the old crust and fill the pie properly. very very sad...

I thought I was getting the delicious French silk pie I've bought multiple times at Sam's club. What a disappointment when we cut into it. The chocolate is not the smooth consistency it used to be and it was not the normal crust. The whipped topping was not as light as it used to be, it felt like something that would clog my arteries right away. I will not be purchasing this again, in fact, I may take it back as it's much more expensive than the original wonderful pie.

I'd give it zero stars if I could. Nasty - primarily whip cream...literally 3/4 whip cream to 1/4 chocolate pudding. The whip cream had a chemical taste and although it had been in the fridge all day, didnt feel cool Hard pass - please do not waste your money. We took a couple bites then dumped the entire thing in the garbage.

I always viewed the Sam's Club French Silk as one of the best, and one of my favorites. Sadly, I can no longer say that. They changed the crust to some chocolate crust that doesn't hold up very well. The filling was slightly runny, even after letting it sit in the fridge for a few hours after purchasing. It also seemed like there were less chocolate curls on top than in previous years. I've been waiting months for them to bring back the French Silk, so to say that I'm disappointed is an understatement.

Bring back the original! If its good and it sells leave it alone. We look forward to FRENCH Silk Pie each season and we are extremely dissapointed. Sams keeps making changes to the good stuff for no reason...like the cinnamon rolls debacle. Please bring French Silk back.

This pie is so good! I liked the old pie too but this ones chocolate crust is to die for. Another review mentioned the filling was like chocolate pudding and i think the consistency of if it similar to pudding but it's much richer and sweeter than pudding. I love this pie!

So disappointed that Sam's has changed this pie. The biggest issue is the crust. It used to be flaky; now it's like a soggy Oreo. Chocolete filling is runny and lacks the flavor of their original French Silk pie.The whipped cream topping is gummy and flavorless. PLEASE bring back the old recipe!

If I could give it a zero I would. I loved the Sam's chocolate pie for years and looked forward to it becoming available again. After trying this year's version, I will NEVER buy it again.The filling is a runny mess and the flavor is just not there. It's a shame you made a cheaper pie that turned out to be awful.