New recipe - Not good at all, agree with the others- bring back the flaky pie crust, the chocolate pie crust just crumbles. The whole recipe is different than the previous pie, which used to be so good, a family fav. Won't be buying this one again

I want my French silk pie back. This is NOT it. The replacement is edible but nothing more than a regular chocolate pie with too much whipped cream and a crumb crust with a weird consistency. Please bring back the old pie!

I can't believe they ruined their classic french silk pie with this new recipe. It used to be the best french silk pie on the market. Whoever made this decision should be fired. Very disappointing. We won't be buying it again.

The French Silk Pie from 2024 and earlier was amazing. This new "pie" is an abomination. It has a cheap plastic taste and honestly I threw out the pie after the entire family refused to finish the first slice. 🤢

I absolutely love this pie with the gram cracker crust better. I don't care for the chocolate crust. Way too rich. Please bring back the gram cracker crust!

Just requested a refund the entire pie Tastes like aerosol spray. complete chemical taste. unbearable, we're all having stomach issues now. And that is the only thing we have eaten. this needs to be fixed

I don't know whose fault it is but this new recipe of the French silk pie is utterly disgusting! This has became a holiday staple for so many families and now it's not edible. Ours went in the garbage. I'm just glad we tried it before Christmas.

Sam's French silk pie has always been my favorite. I drive an hour every year, multiple times to get one. This new crust is disgusting and the pie is not good. Bring back the old pie. I'm heartbroken.

What happened to the nice 16" French Silk pie?? Like Anne the other reviewer I waited 9 months for the "original" and best French silk pie ever! Now, a 10" pie with chocolate crust? Come on Sam's! Bring back the original please!! TY

Absolutely disgusting One bite it went to the trash, 1 star because it looked pretty. Makes me not ever want to eat a silk pie from anywhere. after this one.