Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark 10" Chocolate Silk Pie, 36 oz. for
Member's Mark 10" Chocolate Silk Pie, 36 oz.
3.5 out of 5 stars
stars380 ratings200 reviews
  1. 5 stars51% (194)
  2. 4 stars8% (32)
  3. 3 stars6% (23)
  4. 2 stars7% (28)
  5. 1 star27% (103)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 131-140 of 200 reviews
Jan 22, 2026
CHRIS
1 out of 5 stars review

bring back the old recipe!

New recipe - Not good at all, agree with the others- bring back the flaky pie crust, the chocolate pie crust just crumbles. The whole recipe is different than the previous pie, which used to be so good, a family fav. Won't be buying this one again

Helpful?6R77087G340018045722952
Feb 6, 2026
NICHOLAS
1 out of 5 stars review

The French Silk Pie from 2024 and earlier was amazing. This new "pie" is an abomination. It has a cheap plastic taste and honestly I threw out the pie after the entire family refused to finish the first slice. 🤢

Helpful?6R77087G340018045722952
Mar 2, 2026
PAUL
1 out of 5 stars review

Get the old version back.

The chocolate pie you sold last year was awesome but this revised version is of poor quality. You can taste the chemicals in the pie. Please change it back. Last years pie was delicious. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE get the old version back.

Helpful?6R77087G340018045722952
Feb 2, 2026
Jenny
1 out of 5 stars review

chemical taste and stomach issues

Just requested a refund the entire pie Tastes like aerosol spray. complete chemical taste. unbearable, we're all having stomach issues now. And that is the only thing we have eaten. this needs to be fixed

Helpful?6R77087G340018045722952
Dec 8, 2025
Thomas
1 out of 5 stars review

Disappointing

The chocolate crust on this pie tastes horrible! Idk why they had to change the crust. We made a special trip to get this pie when we saw it was in stock. We're so disappointed! Bring back the original crust!!!

Helpful?6R77087G340018045722952
Dec 7, 2025
CHRISTOPHER
1 out of 5 stars review

Don't waste the money

I have waited for months for the chocolate pie to come back and now this is what we get?!? Bring back the original! Horrible crust, not the original pie crust. Filling tastes like bland pudding. So disappointed

Helpful?6R77087G340018045722952
Dec 5, 2025
WARREN
1 out of 5 stars review

What Happened to 16" French silk pie!!

What happened to the nice 16" French Silk pie?? Like Anne the other reviewer I waited 9 months for the "original" and best French silk pie ever! Now, a 10" pie with chocolate crust? Come on Sam's! Bring back the original please!! TY

Helpful?6R77087G340018045722952
Dec 27, 2025
KEVIN
1 out of 5 stars review

Save your money for something else!

I have been buying these from Sam's for years, this is definitely not what it was. The crust is a crumbly mess and the chocolate taste is more like mousse than the French silk it used to be.

Helpful?6R77087G340018045722952
Dec 9, 2025
Jennifer
5 out of 5 stars review

Will Buy Again!

The chocolate crust is delicious and has a nice texture. The filling was smooth and decadent. It's a rich dessert (in a good way!) that pairs well with a cup of coffee. I'd buy this again!

Helpful?6R77087G340018045722952
Dec 29, 2025
SANDY
2 out of 5 stars review

Not the same... so disappointed.

It tastes cheap like the frozen pies that you thaw and eat. I thought it looked tinier and cheaper right away. I assumed shrinkflation, but it was worse. As others commented, the chocolate cookie crust is not typical and kinda gross.

Helpful?6R77087G340018045722952