Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Hickory Smoked Whole Turkey, priced per pound for
Member's Mark Hickory Smoked Whole Turkey, priced per pound
4.5 out of 5 stars
stars1,999 ratings859 reviews
  1. 5 stars81% (1,624)
  2. 4 stars6% (119)
  3. 3 stars4% (88)
  4. 2 stars2% (46)
  5. 1 star6% (122)

Member photos

  • +23 images
Sort by |
Showing 301-310 of 859 reviews
Dec 25, 2023
Dojo
5 out of 5 stars review

Thanks, Sam’s Club and “Mom of 5”!

I read many of these reviews before I purchased two for Thanksgiving. “Mom of 5” had a recipe for warming the turkey. She put the turkey in a pan with chicken broth, lemon juice, and fresh herbs. I used sage, rosemary, and thyme. Cover in foil. Heat for an hour or so. Best turkey my family has ever had. Bought more for Christmas. LOVE, LOVE, LOVE.

Helpful?772V9UU5LTZ817867508043
Dec 25, 2021
SherryC
5 out of 5 stars review

BEST Turkey I have ever eaten!

Oh my goodness, where to start! I bought this turkey for Thanksgiving for my husband and I to have for dinner! It was a smaller one at a little over 4 pounds! Let me tell you, when I say it tasted so delicious, that just doesn't do it justice! It was heavenly! I went back to Sam's Club to buy more of them for me and for my adult children and their families, but they were all gone! How sad I was! I ask the butcher and he said maybe they would get more in for Christmas, but that never happened! I would be willing to pay double the selling price per pound if I could just find them again!

Helpful?772V9UU5LTZ817867508043
Dec 26, 2025
CYNTHIA
5 out of 5 stars review

Elevate your dinner!!

I started to walk past this turkey. I have had other brands and they had an artificial taste but this one was so delicious, so tender and so so easy to prepare. Took it to a family gathering and got so many compliments on taste and questions about where I got it. Everyone thought I smoked this turkey myself. It is definitely worth the purchase.

Helpful?772V9UU5LTZ817867508043
Dec 10, 2025
CJ
5 out of 5 stars review

Best turkey hands down!

Best turkey hands down! It has a mild smoked taste and a nice pink tint. With it being fully cooked we have saved a lot of time and oven space during the holidays by being able to just toss it into our countertop roaster for warming. We have tried butterballs smoked turkey and it just didn't compare in regards to texture and moistness. The price per lb is obviously more than the deals you could get at a local grocery but the minimal work required to prepare this turkey makes it worth the cost. It's so worth it that I will buy a 2nd one to store in the freezer and use it throughout the year.

Helpful?772V9UU5LTZ817867508043
Nov 28, 2025
Nonsensely
5 out of 5 stars review

Best idea in decades!

Ordered this on a whim… best idea I've had in many years! Covered with loose foil, added a few cups of water to roaster and cooked on a rack. Made gravy with the few Smokey drippings by adding more water. Super juicy, tender, and delicious! My family has been picking on it over an hour after ‘dinner' was served. Can't wait to make killer smoked Turkey salad tomorrow! Going to order one for Christmas as well. Bravo Members Mark!

Helpful?772V9UU5LTZ817867508043
Nov 21, 2025
Jennifer
5 out of 5 stars review

I will not use any other turkey for Thanksgiving but this one. I made one last year and it was a big hit. My husband is a ham guy and preferred this turkey over ham! It is so easy to make you don't just have to save it for Thanksgiving. More time spent with the family instead of in the kitchen basting a turkey for hours.

Helpful?772V9UU5LTZ817867508043
Dec 21, 2025
ELIZABETH
1 out of 5 stars review

Yuck! Tastes like ham.

Not sure why everyone raves about this turkey. It tastes like ham with a weird texture. It was so awful we ended up throwing it in the trash. Judging by how many were left in the store after Thanksgiving, we're not the only ones that do not care for it. They were marked down and were practically giving them away.

Helpful?772V9UU5LTZ817867508043
Nov 24, 2025
Sarah
5 out of 5 stars review

Delicious and easy to prepare, love this turkey!

This turkey was delicious and super easy to cook. I will purchase again. I don't love cooking large meats like this, and this one you just take it out of the package and warm it in the oven. Our turkey was 12 lbs and served 12 people. Great item, highly recommend.

Helpful?772V9UU5LTZ817867508043
Nov 21, 2025
James
1 out of 5 stars review

Stay Away. Went into the trash.

I hated the smoked flavor. Most of the time a "Smoked Turkey" doesn't taste this way. This taste like liquid smoke was injected into the turkey. Best way to describe it is as if the turkey had a chemical after taste of fake smoke flavor. Absolutely horrid. Dogs wouldn't even eat it. Went directly into the trash. Do not buy.

Helpful?772V9UU5LTZ817867508043
Nov 21, 2025
MITCHELL
5 out of 5 stars review

i have been purchasing these turkeys for the last 4 years for Thanksgiving and they are the best,i souve mine for 12 ,then put in fridge once it cools down then put on my smoker Thanksgiving morning for about 4 hours to heat it up,my family loves it,they said it's the best they ever ate

Helpful?772V9UU5LTZ817867508043