Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for The Good Charcoal Lump Charcoal - 27.5 lbs. for
The Good Charcoal Lump Charcoal - 27.5 lbs.
4 out of 5 stars
stars
1,319 ratings752 reviews
  1. 5 stars64% (848)
  2. 4 stars9% (113)
  3. 3 stars7% (96)
  4. 2 stars6% (77)
  5. 1 star14% (185)

Member photos

  • +86 images
Sort by |
Showing 41-50 of 752 reviews
Nov 16, 2026
Reviewer name: Mo
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

good quality

very good

Helpful?2IBDXR3NAHXO15596657169
Jun 30, 2026
Reviewer name: Alexander
2 out of 5 stars
2 out of 5 stars review

Should be called "Charcoal Nuggets"

i figured a bag this big should have some decent sized chunks....not the case. the whole bag was filled with nuggets about the size of a charcoal briquette or smaller. it's a big bag, for the money but the smaller pieces burn hotter and faster than larger lump charcoal, so you go through it twice as fast.

Helpful?2IBDXR3NAHXO15596657169
reply from The Good Charcoal Team

Hey, thanks for the detailed feedback. A bag this size should give you a good mix with some solid larger chunks in there, so a whole bag of nuggets isn't what you should be ending up with. That much uniformity on the small end usually means a bag took a rough ride in handling before it got to you, and that's worth us looking into. One thing worth knowing on the burn. Our Acacia is some of the densest hardwood you can cook over, so it wants to run hot, but that's actually where airflow becomes your friend. Dial back your vents and you can really control it, holding a long clean even burn with little to no flare ups or sparks. Once you get it dialed in it goes a lot further than you'd expect. And it's not your typical charcoal source either. We harvest Acacia bush, not old growth trees, which clears overgrowth that's been choking out native grasslands. That effort has restored habitat across an area about the size of Texas and even helped bring some cheetah populations back from the critically endangered list. Real charcoal doing real good. Send us a few photos at hello@thegoodcharcoal.com and let us know which Sam's Club you grabbed it from and we'll get you sorted out.

Jul 4, 2026
Reviewer name: Doris
2 out of 5 stars
2 out of 5 stars review

No big lumps!!

I was so excited to see this bag of lump charcoal at a really good price. Immediately put one in the cart, almost bought 2, glad I didn't. Not happy with the product. We have a BGE and it burns better and longer with bigger chunks. 4" to 6". This small stuff burns HOT and fast, so we had to really manage our fire way more than usual. Maybe we got a bad bag.

Helpful?2IBDXR3NAHXO15596657169
reply from The Good Charcoal Team

Hey Doris, thanks for the thoughtful review, and sorry this first bag didn't wow you the way the price had you hoping. We get it. Depending on your Big Green Egg's grate, our natural mix of piece sizes can be a hassle, and that's a fair thing to be frustrated by. One reason for that mix is that we make our charcoal from Acacia bush rather than cutting down trees, which helps preserve forests and protect natural habitat. It's a tradeoff we believe in, but we know it can mean the sizing isn't always perfect for every setup. On the hot and fast burn, a lot of that comes down to airflow. Acacia is one of the densest hardwoods out there so it wants to run hot, but on a kamado like the BGE that's exactly where you have the most control. Choke those top and bottom vents down and you can hold a long low even burn without babysitting it. That said, if the piece size keeps being a problem for you, we'd really like to make it right. Send us an email at hello@thegoodcharcoal.com and let us know which store you grabbed it from, and we'll take care of you.

May 24, 2026
Reviewer name: anonymous
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

No good for me

Super small pieces and takes a lot to smoke a brisket constantly having to add more. Do your self a favor and pay the extra money for B%26B competition lump it’s 30 bucks but only takes half a back one fire box full last for almost 10 hours in my offset smoker.

Helpful?2IBDXR3NAHXO15596657169
May 4, 2026
Reviewer name: CarlosE
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Poor quality, very small coals

It shouldn't even be called "premium"; it's really the lowest quality charcoal, like production scraps. I bought four bags thinking maybe I was just unlucky with the first three, but with this fourth bag, I confirmed it's extremely poor quality charcoal with pieces too small to even be called charcoal.

Helpful?2IBDXR3NAHXO15596657169
reply from The Good Charcoal Team

Hey Carlos, thanks for taking the time to leave this feedback, and honestly, four bags in, I completely understand the frustration. That's not the experience we want anyone to have, and it's not something we take lightly. Our charcoal is 100% hardwood Acacia with no additives, binders, or fillers, which is what makes it genuinely different from most of what's on the market. But it also means the pieces can vary in size naturally depending on the batch and how it was handled getting to you. That said, what you're describing doesn't sound right, and we'd really like to look into it. Please reach out to us directly at hello@thegoodcharcoal.com with a few photos of what you received and let us know which store you picked these up from. That detail really helps us track things down on our end so we can work to resolve it for you.

Jul 4, 2026
Reviewer name: Chasen
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Maybe they need to change their name to The Bad Charcoal because i mostly got nothing but little pebbles. They were big lumps when I first tried this brand last year now im just have to throw the rest of this bag away. I would've been better off getting Cowboy or B%26B lump Charcoal than this crap.

Helpful?2IBDXR3NAHXO15596657169
reply from The Good Charcoal Team

Hey Chasen, that's a real letdown especially when you had a great bag last year, and we hear you. The good news is nothing's changed about what goes in our bags. It's the same 100% hardwood Acacia, same big lumps you got the first time around. A bag full of little pebbles like you're describing points to it taking a rough ride in handling before it reached you, not a change in the product itself. And don't throw it out just yet, we'd like to make it right. Send us a few photos at hello@thegoodcharcoal.com and let us know which Sam's Club you picked it up from. We'll get you taken care of and back to the bags you remember.

Jul 10, 2026
Reviewer name: Josh
2 out of 5 stars
2 out of 5 stars review

Quickly goes from lump to chips to pellets.

About 20% is lump charcoal, the next 40% is smaller. the next 20-30 is the size of chips. the remaining is almost the size of pellets. Maybe if you used them all at once, you could get 60-80% lump. But if you're like me to buy in bulk to bring a little at a time to BBQ at the beach or to go camping, it will quickly turn into chips and pellets. Will not be buying this again.

Helpful?2IBDXR3NAHXO15596657169
reply from The Good Charcoal Team

Hey Josh, thanks for breaking that down in detail. A little size variation comes with the territory on a natural product like ours, but pellet sized pieces aren't what you should be getting. It should be recognizable, usable lump charcoal top to bottom, and that's not what this bag gave you. We'd like to make it right. Send a few photos to hello@thegoodcharcoal.com and let us know which Sam's Club you grabbed it from and we'll take care of you.

Sep 18, 2024
Reviewer name: Redfin
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Not so good

I'm not one to complain but purchased this The Good Charcoal Lump last week from Sam's Club and the Lump size is less than a quarter coin in size, there was several pieces about 2" but I have never seen Lump charcoal like this, 3" of Lump dust in the bottom of the bag. Trying to light this Lump in a Chimney starter on on the grill grate much of this Good Charcole Lump falls through the grill grate or Chimney . Sorry for the negative review but it's just the truth, hopefully your company will outsource large wood pieces in the future.

Helpful?2IBDXR3NAHXO15596657169
reply from The Good Charcoal Team

Dear Redfin, Thank you for your candid feedback. We understand that our hardwood Acacia charcoal, made from the invasive bush, might not meet your expectations or needs depending on your grill setup. We would love to know which grill you’re using so we can look into this issue for you and make it right. Please reach out to us at Hello@TheGoodCharcoal.com, and we’d be happy to assist further.Best regards,The Good Charcoal Team

Apr 27, 2025
Reviewer name: Griller
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

No good.

I have unfortunately purchased this lump charcoal several times in hopes that I just got a “bad bag”. But consistently, the entire bag seems as though it’s the end of the bag. All the pieces are small and it takes forever to get it to start. I won’t be buying this brand ever again. I was very disappointed.

Helpful?2IBDXR3NAHXO15596657169
reply from The Good Charcoal Team

Dear Griller,We appreciate you giving our charcoal several chances and are sorry to hear it has not met your expectations. Our lump charcoal is made from dense Acacia hardwood and is designed to burn hot, clean, and reliably. We would appreciate the opportunity to learn more about your experience and see how we can make it right. Please feel free to reach out to us at Hello@TheGoodCharcoal.com.Hope to hear from you soon, The Good Charcoal TeamBest regards,The Good Charcoal Team

Jun 4, 2024
Reviewer name: Bourbon and Blues BBQ
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

The Good Charcoal is Great!

The Good Charcoal burns long and hot and is our preferred charcoal for all of our competition BBQ cooks as well as home grilling. It's made of pure acacia wood, is sustainably harvested and is 100% chemical-free. All that and now they have new larger bags with handles at a lower price. It's a great value for a premium product!

Helpful?2IBDXR3NAHXO15596657169