Smell good, they are soft but firm so good for young and old. Large sized bag for a great price! Already ordered 2 more in case Sam's stops carrying them!

My dogs love these peanut butter banana treats. They are soft baked and made with all human grade good ingredients. I can give them more then one per the instructions and I don’t feel bad because they are good quality.

Always hungry black lab loves these...can't give her too many but there's no hesitation when I offer them up....she gobbles em right down and waits for another.

Wow, this was a massive bag of dog treats! If it hadn’t said ‘dog’ on the bag, I might’ve tried them myself. They smelled like freshly baked cookies from your local bakery. The texture was just right, and my dog absolutely loved them!

These are my favorite dog treats because I can leave them whole or easily break them apart for weight control and training. They have stayed soft in the treat jar. My 3 labs gobble them up.

I have a German Shepard and a Chihuahua. My GS is kind of finicky trying new things but once she got a taste of it wanted to sit and get more. My Chihuahua is older and I liked that since it is soft in could break it in half and give her a smaller piece. She loved it. She ate it up in no time and came back to sit and was ready for another piece. I am very happy that the ingredients are human-grade and much better for our four-legged friends.

We bought these for our grand dogs AND neighborhood dogs. We have found that at first the dogs are iffy about taking the treat but once they actually eat one they want more and more. Even a few day later when passing by our house they want more. They LOVE these awesome treats!!

I don't give my dogs just anything, so I was hesitant to try this at first. However, reading the ingredients and seeing that it is actually good for them. It gives comfort knowing they are getting good treats. Well, turns out, they love these and get so excited when the bag opens. The bag gives a ratio of treats per day by size and that makes splitting the day into reward periods easy. Soft and smells so good, we almost wanted to eat ourselves. If we didn't know it was a dog treat of course

This bag is huge and will last awhile. When I get treats, they go fast. So, it is nice these will last a lot longer than a week. My Dalmation will eat anything he can get his paws on so it's no surprise he liked them. But my Jack Russel is very picky, he will not eat everything. He does like them though! They are banana and peanut butter flavor, which I was worried wouldn't be popular. But it's a nice little sweet savory treat for my boys. I will purchase again.

Our dog LOVES these treats. they are definitely soft and chewy. Shaped like a 2"x2" paw print., so they are not huge but not small, so basically just the right size. They actually smell really good, not old and stale like some dog treats. Even though they are a medium size treat, they are soft enough that even a smaller dog would be able to eat them. They come in a resealable pouch, so will stay fresh longer. We will for sure be keeping these on hand as a regular pet pantry staple.