The dogs' reaction to this treat determines the rating and they don't hesitate with these when offered. The dogs are old so this soft treat works well for them.

The pups love these treats! A clear favorite. You can give them a variety of treats and these are always the first ones gone and/or the only ones eaten!

These treats are perfect for our medium to large size dogs. The stay fresh packaging is perfect and the treats have stayed soft since arrival. They are shaped like paws as pictured. We have had no adverse effects on our Husky, Australian shepherd, or great dane. They all seem to love them and can't wait for the morning and afternoon snack.

I recently got these treats for my dogs, and I have to say—they’re a hit! The texture is soft and chewy, which makes them easy to break into smaller pieces if needed. The combination of banana and peanut butter smells great (even to me!), and my dogs absolutely loves them. He gets excited every time he sees the bag. I also appreciate that the ingredients seem natural and pet-safe. Overall, it’s a great product that I enjoy giving to my dog, but more importantly, he loves it. Highly recommended!

Literally smells like a peanut butter and banana cookie! I’ve never smalled a dog treat smell so much like a human sweet treat. I have a 14 yr old long hair 5lb chihuahua, and she is a very picky eater. These treats were soft to touch which is required for her to be able to eat. She did not eat right away, but I broke it up and put in her bowl and she devoured the snack. They are good sized treats so one was plenty! No side effects, so far so good!

My daughter and I run a dog sitting business. These treats were used for a few weeks while we had about 20-25 different dogs in and out of our home. We are dog lovers - so I am always on the hunt for treats and things for my own dogs, plus the ones that come to me to stay. These treats were a big hit for the majority of the dogs. We have a few finicky dogs that would not even try them- but for all but about 3 of them— these treats were delicious. I will buy them again.

Good clean ingredients and good value - my dogs are picky and sometimes not as eager with these but overall - i will keep purchasing because of the ingredients.

They are soft and have a strong banana scent. Super cute puppy print shape. I thought they would be great for both of my dogs. I have an older toy poodle and the four year-old bully pit mix. I thought the texture would be good for my toy poodle however she smelled it and then didn't want to have anything to do with it. She wouldn't even try it.. 

Just received the bag of treats today…I like the size of the dog treat itself and the paw print shape is adorable. Nice big bag for what you get. We interact daily with our neighbor’s dog and when we have her one she looked at us like we just made her whole day so safe to say she liked the taste. Now he4es why I give it 3 stars…ingredients show “natural peanut butter FLAVORING” and “natural banana flavoring” while bragging all Over the bag that it’s made with real peanut butter and real banana. Natural flavoring is not the same thing. I also just wish all these companies could learn to make quality products without seed oils, but sunflower oil is at least a little better than others . This isn’t the worst doggy treat product, but if you’re someone who reads the ingredients of everything you buy, it isn’t the best either.

My dog did not have anything to do with this treat but my granddaughter's dog ate them. I guess like people each has there own taste. I would say try it once to see if your pet likes them. They are soft and sm size for small dogs.