Very easy to open and close! You can definitely smell the peanut butter! Very clean as well not messy at all. My dogs loved them! They are human Grade Treats for Dogs.

These looked very good but my puppy didn't like them . He just smelled them and wouldn't even try. He is very picky. I gave then to my granddaughter for her dog .

I love that these pet treats have good cleaning ingredients. Not only to my pets love them, but they actually smell great where most treats smell disgusting on my hands after giving them to my dogs.

My dog loved this treat! She is not a big fan of peanut butter so I was worried she wouldn't like them, but she did! These were great as a treat when she comes back in from going outside to use the bathroom!

I introduced these treats to be given out after bathroom time several times a day, up to three times a day… Within the past week, since I started giving her these, starting two weeks ago, she started having diarrhea, that’s the only change she’s ever had to her diet. I tossed them out and got something else

Perfect dog treat even for training. My dogs favorite and great quality with healthy ingredients.

Both of my dogs loved them and they smell delicious.

Brutis and the Peanut cookies!

My dog loves these treats. Unlike most treats these are soft instead of crunchy. It is nice when your dog eats them they do not crumble and get crumbs everywhere. She could smell the treats before I opened them and was very excited to try them. She was definitely doing tricks for treats.

These Soft & Chewy dog treats are the best dog treats! They smell like a peanut butter cookie—seriously they smell so good! I love that the treats are paw print shaped. I have a toy Aussie, with an ultra sensitive stomach and he’s done just fine with these treats. They are made of clean and real ingredients—human grade! I highly recommend these members mark dog treats for your furry friend!