Thinking the peanut butter cookie would be a huge bit, I was so wrong. Most would not even eat it, or they took it and dropped it, leaving it for the one dog to snag it. Smells like peanut butter. Crumbly

These looked very good but my puppy didn't like them . He just smelled them and wouldn't even try. He is very picky. I gave then to my granddaughter for her dog .

My dog was immediately drawn to these treats. He loved them! They were a bit bigger than expected so I will watch how many I give him in a day. I like that they are on the softer side

Treats smell delicious perfect size for my dog he loves them the ingredients are clean and simple not junk filled like most I would definitely recommend they help train my dog reliable brand.

Very easy to open and close! You can definitely smell the peanut butter! Very clean as well not messy at all. My dogs loved them! They are human Grade Treats for Dogs.

I love that these pet treats have good cleaning ingredients. Not only to my pets love them, but they actually smell great where most treats smell disgusting on my hands after giving them to my dogs.

Maple, my English bulldog LOVED the treat. It actually smells great. It doesn't smell like typical dog food. You can smell the banana and peanut butter. Maple was very happy with this product.

My puppies love it, the ingredients are all organic and really good for your puppies. My puppies are very sensitive to any treats but this one totally works for them

My dog absolutely loves these treats. If she hears the crinkle of the bag, she comes running. The treats are the perfect size and the paw print shape is cute. The treats have a pretty strong smell of banana and peanut butter. I love the clean and limited ingredient list. I highly recommend these dog treats!

Just received the bag of treats today…I like the size of the dog treat itself and the paw print shape is adorable. Nice big bag for what you get. We interact daily with our neighbor’s dog and when we have her one she looked at us like we just made her whole day so safe to say she liked the taste. Now he4es why I give it 3 stars…ingredients show “natural peanut butter FLAVORING” and “natural banana flavoring” while bragging all Over the bag that it’s made with real peanut butter and real banana. Natural flavoring is not the same thing. I also just wish all these companies could learn to make quality products without seed oils, but sunflower oil is at least a little better than others . This isn’t the worst doggy treat product, but if you’re someone who reads the ingredients of everything you buy, it isn’t the best either.