They don't smell bad to me, but my dog who normally eats pretty much any treat won't touch them! Like she actually turns her head away from them as if in disgust. I trust my dog's instincts. Who knows what goes on in "Walmart world" to keep prices lower. I will see if I can return them.

My brother bought these for his dogs. They turned one of his dogs into a treat snob!! Until he bought these one of the dogs was not much of a treat beggar but now when he comes in he sits right by the bag and waits!!! He refuses any of the other treats!!! I now make sure I have a bag at my house!!

I got these to try for my 1 year old dog. She’s a Shih Tzu with a pretty sensitive stomach. A lot of treats I’ve tried, she gets sick and throws up. But these have been great! She likes the flavor and she hasn’t any stomach troubles with them. In fact, they seem to be good for her. I like that the bag recommends how many to give your dog based on their weight. They do not smell. Highly recommend and I hope they keep making these!!!!

Our four Newfoundlands go absolutely stupid for these. All four are picky in different ways, so the fact they are loved by all is still geeking us out. From just “nigh night” cookies to helping to train the puppy, these are working. We just randomly grabbed them thinking we would give them a shot. Now they are part of our permanent arsenal! They are not huge, no where near the size of the milk bone treats, but they work and are perfect for a light snack. HA! For smaller dogs, these might be big. For training purposes, I rip them in quarters or half.

Bought these in July 2025, by August 2025 they were covered in mold. Supposed to be good until Sept 2027. They were kept at cool room temperature, which it was supposed to be. Not sure why this happened but my daughter bought them too and hers molded too within a month.

My dog goes NUTS over these treats! I tried to give her a different treat which she spit it out until she got this one. I cut them in half so she doesn't get too many calories in a day. They're easily breakable with your hands. Stella Bella says 10/10.

My dog unfortunately despises these and won’t eat them.

My dog wouldn’t eat them, just spit them out.

Our fur baby has many food allergies. He loves these and I love knowing that he can have with no health problems.

All 3 pups love these treats, and we love that they’re made from human-food-grade ingredients (they smell yummy!).