We own 4 dogs, of the 4 only one would even try these, and they all love peanut butter. I feel like they were wasted time and money.

None of my 3 dogs seem to like these. They have loved other Member's Mark dog treats in the past, but they really don't like this particular flavor.

Soft but they don't break apart in the bag like other soft treats we have tried. Both of our large breed dogs love them.

These treats my dog loves. I like how they are soft and flavorful. i will continue to buy these for my dog. please keep in stock all the time.

Our Lab who loves all food %26 peanut butter will not eat these. She has never refused a dog treat before.

My three babies like these. I like that they're human grade. They have a chemical smell though. I don't like that.

Good enough soft and easy to break in pieces but made my dog have the most foul farts ever so I won't be repurchasing

I waited a good week to write this just to make sure there were no digestive issues with the treats. My dog has had one a day with no change in bowel movements. They smell pretty good and are not dry and crumbly.

Wow, this was a massive bag of dog treats! If it hadn’t said ‘dog’ on the bag, I might’ve tried them myself. They smelled like freshly baked cookies from your local bakery. The texture was just right, and my dog absolutely loved them!

These are great. My pup loves them and I love that they smell good. A good healthy treat. They are slightly soft so breaking them for training is great. They do not crumble to bad when my pup eats them. These are great for any size dog.