My dog is a huge fan of these treats! They are soft, so easy to split in half or quarters. You can definitely smell the peanut butter when you open the bag. They are 25 kcal/treat, so easy calculate and figure into diet for pups that need to be on one. All I have to do is hold one of these to the door and my normally stubborn dog comes running to the door.

To say my dogs loved these would be an understatement. We have other treats we usually give them but they have chosen these over the others every time. They're soft but not brittle and the perfect size for large and small dogs alike. I do believe we have founf our new permanent treat!

These treats came at the perfect time I had been looking for something healthy for my girls. They love these, and I love them because I can actually read the ingredients. When I say, "Do you want a treat, they both run to the kitchen and sit by the shelf that has the treats.

My dog absolutely loves these treats! When I opened the bag in front of her, she immediately sniffed around the bag, sweetly asking for a treat. It’s a mix of peanut butter and banana, and smells delicious! Each treat looks like a tiny paw print, making them very cute on top of being a preferred treat! The bag is huge too - so many treats!

This was something new I saw at Sam's Club and thought I'd try it. I liked the fact that there are limited ingredients in this treat. I have 3 large dogs and was skeptical that all of them would enjoy this treat as my older girl tends to be on the finicky side. She loves peanut butter but is not a fan of banana. I was pleasantly surprised to see that they ALL love this treat! I like the fact that this is just the right size for my dogs and is soft enough that it can be broken into smaller pieces to use as training treats if needed. It does not leave a lot of crumbs like harder treats may do. The scent is not strong unlike some treats that offer a bacon or a smokey/BBQ scent. To me it smells just slightly of peanut butter. I'm thankful that their breath (and my hands) doesn't smell like smoked jerky or bacon when I give them one. I thought the cost was a little pricey, but the bag does hold a significant number of treats so I expect it will last for a while. Also, being that all my dogs seem to really enjoy this treat I feel that it was a worthwhile purchase. I will continue to buy this item and recommend it for your dogs.

My dogs really enjoy these soft treats. At first, they didn’t know what to think as they are used to getting meat flavored treats, but after they tried them, both dogs really enjoyed them. They have a nice scent and seem appetizing for our beloved family animals.

My dogs seem to love these treats! They’re a good size and appear easy for them to eat. I don’t think they smell particularly good, but I don’t think I’m supposed to since I’m not canine. There are notes of banana and peanut butter, as there should be since those are key ingredients. I think they're worth a try for your dog(s) and my pictures will further convince you.

My dogs loved these treats! I liked that they are not made with any fillers or unnecessary ingredients like most other treats, they are a cute paw shape and are soft enough that even our smaller dog had no problem gobbling it right up. All 3 dogs immediately were begging for a second one. The back of the package includes a handy treat per day guide too! The only thing that I did not like about them was the smell, but that can be overlooked easily!

Both of our dogs liked these. They are soft instead of crunchy. They were able to eat them without making a mess and they are a good size for a quick treat. The only negative from our household is that it has a strong smell of banana when you open the bag and my husband doesn't like bananas. However, the dogs seem to like it anyway.

My dogs seemed to really like this one more then the rest. Greta my Rott loves them and would literally eat them all if given the chance. I like that they are made from healthy ingredients and are soft enough that I can break into smaller pieces for my smaller dogs.