These treats are great. The package is huge first of all. 48oz huge! I got the peanut butter and banana soft chewy treats. The treats are paw shaped. Adorable! And they smell great! You can smell the banana and peanut butter. Our dog Rosie loved them!! And I love that they are made in the USA!

The two dogs really enjoyed these treats and even started smelling the package before we even opened it. Peanut butter is how we get them in the bath so it’s literally their favorite treat. Both doggies were doing tricks and posing for pictures to get another treat. My smaller dog did bite it my big girl just ate it even too quick for me to record. We have been using and nothing seems like it’s a problem we have never had this brand before but we might be switching if they continue to love working for these treats

The Members Mark brand of dog treats that are made with peanut butter and banana make my dogs go bananas over them. I appreciate the fact that they are the perfect size and chewy. The paw print shape is very cute. I also like the fact that it’s healthy and nutritious for my dogs.

My loves these treats. I am always on the look out for a chewy treat as he doesn't really like crunchy ones. The only thing is they are kind of big so I cut them into fourths. I do this so I can give him multiple treats during our walks when he is heeling well, sitting at crosswalks...etc. Without cutting them they would be a one and done. But that is just what I use them for. They also smell good, which is not always the case with dog treats.

My dog absolutely loves these treat and I don’t blame her. They smell delicious and have a soft texture. It wouldn’t be hard to mistake these for human treats. I’m not only impressed with how much she likes them, the smell, the calorie count, but also how well the bag stays sealed. These are also “safe” to put in your pocket as they don’t leave a residue either.

Our 3 very big dogs love these treats! They come running when they see me approaching the Soft & Chewy Treats. I thinks it’s the peanut butter, but it could also be the bananas in them. I like that I can break them up into different sizes. I bought multiple bags, since it is only here for a limited time. I suggest you load up as well!

So, Member's Mark Peanut Butter and Banana Dog Treats are dog approved. I have 3 dogs and 2 of them are known to eat anything and the last one is so picky. But even he liked the doggie treats which is very rare for him, and I am so glad he does like them. Because he is senior dog and needs to put on more weight so, I am very grateful for these treats because they will help me do that.

The treats arrived in a resealable heavy duty foil package. They smelled very good when I opened them and the package has the right amount of crinkle to alert the dogs of a goodie coming their way. The treats were soft and solid, easy to break into pieces to split a single treat up. Both dogs gobbled them up and wanted more. Even my picky eater grand pups decided they really liked these treats. You can smell both the peanut butter and banana flavors making it smell like a fresh loaf of banana bread each time you open the bag.

Our dog LOVES these treats. they are definitely soft and chewy. Shaped like a 2"x2" paw print., so they are not huge but not small, so basically just the right size. They actually smell really good, not old and stale like some dog treats. Even though they are a medium size treat, they are soft enough that even a smaller dog would be able to eat them. They come in a resealable pouch, so will stay fresh longer. We will for sure be keeping these on hand as a regular pet pantry staple.

My pup LOVES these soft cookies. They smell good enough to make me want to eat them. When my pup sees the package he immediately sits and gives me "the look". He then eats it very slowly to savor the goodness. (he is a lab mix) Only problem is that I can't find them anymore.