My three dogs have always eaten the Members Mark chicken or salmon kibble. But they were out of both for a long time. Had try the lamb and rice. The kibble size is small.and our dogs did not want to eat. They are normally very good eaters. Had to switch to a non-members mark brand since our store and online were still out of the chicken and salmon. Switching dog foods should be gradual but I didn't have a choice. Our geriatric dog had gastric upset.

The puppies seem to like this dog food. The ingredients seem to be good. I am unsure of who the distributor is of this dogfood. That kind of bothers me. It is rarely in stock and that makes it inconvenient to start a dogfood, and then have to switch it up , because it is out of stock.

This has been our preferred dog food for more than 20 years. Our dogs have always been healthy. Ingredients are comparable to more expensive "fancy" brands, and way superior to the traditional "commercial" brands. We have switched from lamb to chicken to salmon, always 1st ingredient. Excellent product.

My dogs liked the food but will not purchase again. They are sensitive to chicken and even though it’s labeled as lamb and rice, chicken meal is the second ingredient. I wanted it to work because of the probiotics. I wish they would bring back the beef and rice that did not contain chicken meal.

The food is very good, my dog loves it! However, the new packaging doesn't seal. The old bag kept the food much fresher. I also used to buy the fish recipe dog food, and I haven't bought it anymore since the smell is very strong and is all over the house. It did not happen with the old bag.

3 stars -l have l have 5 adult dogs and 4 month old puppies. They’re picky w dog food and this wasn’t a big hit ..they eat it when they’re hungry enough when l don’t offer a substitute or a meal topper but l don’t buy again. I switched to science dt for the puppies and a different variety for the dogs = best g improvement.

The dogs seem to like it, and I like the way it’s formed. small squares, versus round, brown, and full of dyes. The price has gotten to be ridiculous so this is probably the last time I’ll be able to afford to buy it. What’s with the greed all of a sudden? Food has gotten out of control even for the pets. Lower the prices

We compared ingredients to what we were feeding our dog (Nutro Lamb/Rice). Very close, yet less expensive than at the pet food stores and Sams always has plenty available when we need it. Our dog knows when it is time to eat and loves this food! Very easy on digestion.

This food had a very strong odor and made my dogs sick and caused vomiting. I've used this food in the past on an regular basis with no issues. Whom ever makes the food for Sam's Club need to be advised. I had throw 40 lbs of dog food away and wash out my dog food container, but had thrown away the bag so I couldn't take it back. I switched to Brand name dog food and pets are doing fine.

We switch from chicken to lamb after the chicken had been recalled for salmonella. Our dog is very skeptical of it, and went from gobbling every meal dog to becoming a grazer after the whole experience. I don’t think the food is bad but our dog had a harder time adjusting to it.