My dogs love this food! I have always fed them Pro Plan lamb and rice but was having trouble with bugs in the bags upon opening and I had to return it so I decided to try this. They love it and it is 40% cheaper than my old dog food!

My dog seemed hesitant at first but loves it now. I usually fed her Blue Buffalo Chicken and Brown Rice but she ended up not liking chicken. She loves it now and it helps that it is much cheaper and still a high quality food.

My dogs eat it up and doesn’t smell too bad for dog food (I’ve smelled some really nasty ones, this is do-able for me and fairly mild imo, doesn’t stop the doggos from going to town on it though!). My only complaint is that this is a vary large bag and does **not** have any way to reseal the bag once opened…no zipper or anything like I’ve seen on many others this size. I don’t have a food storage container large enough to fit the entire bag (only about 2/3 of the bag) so I have to clip it in hopes I’ve clipped it off enough it won’t be attracting bugs later on.

We switch from chicken to lamb after the chicken had been recalled for salmonella. Our dog is very skeptical of it, and went from gobbling every meal dog to becoming a grazer after the whole experience. I don’t think the food is bad but our dog had a harder time adjusting to it.

3 stars -l have l have 5 adult dogs and 4 month old puppies. They’re picky w dog food and this wasn’t a big hit ..they eat it when they’re hungry enough when l don’t offer a substitute or a meal topper but l don’t buy again. I switched to science dt for the puppies and a different variety for the dogs = best g improvement.

We compared ingredients to what we were feeding our dog (Nutro Lamb/Rice). Very close, yet less expensive than at the pet food stores and Sams always has plenty available when we need it. Our dog knows when it is time to eat and loves this food! Very easy on digestion.

The food is very good, my dog loves it! However, the new packaging doesn't seal. The old bag kept the food much fresher. I also used to buy the fish recipe dog food, and I haven't bought it anymore since the smell is very strong and is all over the house. It did not happen with the old bag.

Love the idea of the ingredient list, with glucosamine and better sources protein but my dogs refuse to eat this or the beef flavor. No more Members Mark for us. 5 year old great pyrenees/german shepherd mix and a 1 year old lab/hound and they’re experiencing clear digestive distress, from both ends. Something is really wrong here.

My Golden seems to like this food. I've tried more expensive brands and she doesn't seem to like them nearly as much as this one. I also like the smaller size of the kibble since it seems she swallows a lot of her food whole without chewing. The more expensive brands with larger kibble make her choke, but this one not so much.

My three dogs have always eaten the Members Mark chicken or salmon kibble. But they were out of both for a long time. Had try the lamb and rice. The kibble size is small.and our dogs did not want to eat. They are normally very good eaters. Had to switch to a non-members mark brand since our store and online were still out of the chicken and salmon. Switching dog foods should be gradual but I didn't have a choice. Our geriatric dog had gastric upset.