My dogs absolutely love these treats. The treats are soft so I am able to break them apart and use them in behavior training with the puppy. The ingredients are all natural.

I bought this product twice and not only does my dog go crazy over this treat but the neighborhood dogs do too. By far this treat is the best for low KCals (14) for each size piece. For less than $20 per 3lb bag this is a also a great deal.

My dog loves these and they are his favorite of all. Please don't discontinue them. They break into smaller pieces easily for smaller dogs and most of the bag once opened can be frozen until more is needed.

PLEASE restock these! It is a great option for dogs with chicken allergies. My dog loved them and there are so few good, affordable options that aren’t chicken!

Although slightly fishy, my lab loves them! I use these as his high reward treat. They are like a soft baked cookie. I break them up and give him a little here and there.

These were as hard as a rock! The last ones were larger and soft. These I couldn’t cut with a sharp steak knife! Nothing like the last time we bought these. It says they are 2 in. in size but these measure 1.

These are new to my 13-year-old dog, but she eats them when offered and seems to like them. They are made of healthy ingredients, but their smell is difficult to withstand. However, I will continue to offer to SadieMae because they’re healthy. I literally hold my nose when offering.

These were my dog's favorite treats! The last few bags have been very different in smell and texture. I reached out to the company, and they said it was due to a new oven. I have yet to have a bag that is similar to how they previously were. Hoping they will go back to the soft, salmon smelling treats like before! Won't be continuing to purchase if they don't.

I like these treats and my dog loves them. The density is just right to break up into bite size training bits. I actually used scissors to cut into small bits but it's easy to break up with fingers. Works very well for training. The "smell" some people mentioned is not an issue. Good price for a very high quality treat.

My dog loves them. They aren't exactly "bites," as they are about 2" in diameter, but they break into pieces easily ; I break them into four pieces. The first and second of four ingredients are Scottish salmon and sweet potatoes. Fingers crossed that Sams always offers them.