Seven is very happy that Sam's thought about him, since he can only have Salmon . No beef,chicken, and no turkey.

My pittie loves these!!! She'll do every trick in her her bag of tricks for one. And I don't feel bad about giving them to her because the ingredients are great. And they even stink like salmon

Only giving 2 stars due to a formula change. They are no longer soft, salmon smelling chews. They are smaller, no real smell and a texture that is strange as it never broke in half before, now it breaks like densely filled cookie. We have been buying these for a year or more and I had a couple bags stocked up. I just had to purchase new supply and am sorely disappointed in these treats as I am no longer confident in the ingredients. For the price of these premium treats, I hope the company hears the feedback and goes back to the original formula as I will not be buying anymore and returning the extra I bought.

Not the same ingredients as they used to be. I have a food restrictive dog and we were so excited when we found these a few months ago. She loved them! Now I just received 3 bags in the mail and all three felt strange like they are stale.

My babies loved these and recently the new batch seems dry and stale. The overwhelming fish smell is gone which my furs loved. Now they are questioning me.

I have purchased these for along time. My dog loved them. Having severe allergies, salmon is his main diet. My last purchase, I noticed immediately they looked different. They no longer had the rich dark color. Got them home and opened them. They are smaller and no longer have the salmon (fishy) smell. My dog could tell as well. He used to get so excited to have one of these. Now he sniffs at them. By appearance and smell, it's obvious that the company decided to cut cost where they are mainly made of sweet potatoes. You lost a customer and my doggie lost his favorite treat. 💔

These used to be my dogs, absolute favorite treats. They were so excited every time I would even go for the bag. I don’t know what happened recently, but they changed the formula or something. They used to be dark brown and smooth. Now they are light brown, and kind of fuzzy textured. They smell like ammonia or vinegar now and my dogs will no longer eat them. I have no idea why they changed.

Our 2 dogs used to absolutely love these treats - they were soft and chewy and excellent for training, but quality has went downhill recently. Now the treats are much lighter in color, much more dry, and fall apart when trying to split them in two. The dogs don't care for them anymore either - it's a shame because they were a good value and provided a great option for training purposes.

The lastest purchase - product was dry and fuzzy All other purchases of the same product was moist and smooth. Seemed dried out or old or both

My dogs wouldn’t eat them. Very fishy smelling. My 3 dogs (shitzu / maltipoo and a chihuahua. Was gonna take them Back but didn’t wanna look like a wierdo returning dog treats