My dogs love them

Dogs like them

My dogs love them

Dogs loved them

My chow loves them.

They have a fishy smell.

Great dog treat

My dogs love these. I have used them for training and they were great! HOWEVER recently this year appears to be a complete formula change. The dogs are not as crazy about them. Hopefully Sam’s and the manufacturer realize this was not a good change and go back to the old formula. I am buying a bag today but will be shopping for other treats to help perk up the dogs.

Whatever you do, do not give your dog these treats. Our Doberman had one treat, and then became obsessed and started demanding MORE. He stands by the bag location and barks nonstop. I also think they gave him some added energy (that he did not need). He suddenly was filled with the Zoomies. You’ve been warned.

My dog will do just about anything to get these treats. She loves them. They don't smell any worse than her regular food, which is Origen, and really only when you open up the bag. The scent doesn't linger in the air. It's fish. It's going to smell a bit. The dogs happen to like it that way. I bought a bag for my friend's dog and he loves them too. I see they are out of stock. If Sam's discontinues these I'm going to have a fit. They always seem to do that when you find something you really love. Why? These have great ratings.