Well the dogs like these but we humans do not. They make a terrible mess all over the place where they eat them since they break into small pieces which the dogs leave behind.

We have three dogs and they all refused to eat this treat. Joking I put it in one of their mouths and they spit it out. Literally. I have a full bag if anyone wants to try them for their dog. Lol.

My dog loved the Member's Mark brand of these beef sticks before they stopped making them a few years ago. So glad a version of them is back! A great crunchy treat for my pup!

Just bought these and will be throwing them away. I thought they would be chewy but they are hard and extremely brittle. It's like feeding glass to your pet. They appear to have a potential to be extremely dangerous for pet's intestines.

My dogs love these! I have a 78 lb. greyhound and a 50 lb. shepherd mix. I like that they contain only one ingredient: beef. They're extremely crunchy. I break them in half and so they take a break between the 2 pieces. I would've given 5 stars, but had to take off a star because they don't last and are gone in seconds.

My dogs love these. Beware though, they look like a bully stick, but are not. They are crunchy treats, and yes, they break apart, but there is no clean up in my house needed as the dogs make sure to pick up every last crumble. So, for me and my boys, these work and they do not have any weird ingredients which is the added bonus! Always keep them stocked in our house!

Not sure what's going on. My dog used to love these. This last bag they seem to be nothing but air wrapped in a hard casing. I suppose this will be my last bag. To bad though because this was the only treat my pup liked. She wont even finish a 1/4 of a stick now.

Please bring these back in store! Both our dogs LOVE these treats!! We have one large breed and one small breed, and they love them equally. We only give a small portion of the stick to the small dog. They love the fantastic crunchy sound and flavor!

We hand these out nightly in a rubber Kong bone, keeps my pitbull rescues chewing for an hour. Easy to break into halves or quarters when I have smaller foster pups. Have enjoyed them for a year without issues and always keep them in hand. Without being stuffed in a toy, they are quick chews- but dogs still love them.

Having a large dog who's allergic to just about every typical ingredient in dog treats, I find these fantastic. ONE ingredient: Beef. Yes, they make a mess sometimes, but I have a german shepherd. It's easier to vacuum up the crumbs in one location than the hair in all locations. ha!