They are not a soft chewy. They are very brittle and break up as the dog chews on them and make a mess.

Ordered online and didn't know how long they were, but they break easily and my smaller dogs love them.

My dear old companion loves these treats. He’s only 15 lbs. so I give him a third at a time as a treat.

My dog's (both giant dogs) love these. They are a great alternative to the old Members Mark Beef Sticks that they no longer sell.

These are made for a larger size dog. I bought them for my terrier and my chihuahua, I have to break them into 1/4. They really like them though

My dogs didn't care for them. They are a weird crunchy hollow stick. They shatter when chewed and small pieces go everywhere. Won't buy them again.

Tried to give them to my two heelers and they wanted nothing to do with them, and they never walked away from a treat.

Well the dogs like these but we humans do not. They make a terrible mess all over the place where they eat them since they break into small pieces which the dogs leave behind.

Excellent item. My dog loves them. Just got the the other day and every time I open the bag he is at my feet waiting for his treat. Definitely buying again.

We have three dogs and they all refused to eat this treat. Joking I put it in one of their mouths and they spit it out. Literally. I have a full bag if anyone wants to try them for their dog. Lol.