My dog loves these treats! I love them because of the clean ingredient list. They are made with 100% beef.

My dog's (both giant dogs) love these. They are a great alternative to the old Members Mark Beef Sticks that they no longer sell.

My dogs does not favor this product. Nor other dogs I meet. Poor quality product a dog does even like

These are great and my dogs love them. These are beef sticks and my dogs want one every day. These are freeze dried and only beef nothing else.

Not recommend for larger aggressive cheweres. My dog likes them but they don't last 3 minutes. They are kind of a hollow treat, not a chew bone

My two dogs love these sticks. They only eat raw food so these treats work well with their diet and they love them.

My dog really likes these beef sticks. They are very dry and will crumble easily but as I said my dog likes them.

These are too messy. My dogs bite into them and they shatter into small crumbs. I won't be getting any more of these treats.

My dogs did not like these and they are ridiculously messy! Wish i had taken them back especially for the price.

All beef, my dogs love crunching them, no crumbs left over. I hope Sams club continues to stock this item.