Our 3 minature schnauzer love these, suprising these are easy to break. The pups really chew these up

All beef, my dogs love crunching them, no crumbs left over. I hope Sams club continues to stock this item.

My dogs really really really love these beef sticks, my only drawback is that they crumble into small crumb pieces, other than that, it’s all good

These beef sticks were an absolute hit with our Golden doodle! Now she sits by the pantry door hoping we will get the hint!

My dogs does not favor this product. Nor other dogs I meet. Poor quality product a dog does even like

Dogs love them…I break in half for a treat and they last a few minutes…maybe 5. I’d love to find smaller ones lik these for the dogs.

These beef sticks are the best treat for our dogs. They do the happy dance every morning! Please keep these in your inventory!

These are vey brittle and shatter into tiny pieces when they chew. Lots of little pieces to sweep up, plus they are not fond of them.

All three of my dogs did not eat this beef stick. They actually turned their heads away from the product. Looks like poop. Returned the product.

My dogs didn't care for them. They are a weird crunchy hollow stick. They shatter when chewed and small pieces go everywhere. Won't buy them again.