Dogs love them…I break in half for a treat and they last a few minutes…maybe 5. I’d love to find smaller ones lik these for the dogs.

These treats are fantastic. Be SURE to break them so as not to give your pup more than he should have at one time.

My dogs love these, doesn't irritate the sensitive stomach a couple have. Doesn't last long but that's okay

I have been waiting forever for these to come back. I’m so happy they have. They are longer lasting than a normal treat and my dogs love them!

Gone too fast - even the smallest dog can get through one in a couple of minutes. We prefer treats that will last longer for that price.

My dogs didn't care for them. They are a weird crunchy hollow stick. They shatter when chewed and small pieces go everywhere. Won't buy them again.

Our dogs love the flavor. We break them in half so they last longer. Keeps the dogs chewing for 30 minutes.

My dog really likes these beef sticks. They are very dry and will crumble easily but as I said my dog likes them.

We have two dogs 1 mix breed approx 70 lbs and a 15lbs shih tzu they both love these sticks it will keep the shih tzu busy for hrs.

She eats them but doesn't get excited about them. I appreciate that they are just beef with no byproducts.