Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Wild Caught Cod Fillet, priced per pound for
Member's Mark Wild Caught Cod Fillet, priced per pound
4.1 out of 5 stars
stars1,999 ratings1,340 reviews
  1. 5 stars60% (1,206)
  2. 4 stars18% (353)
  3. 3 stars6% (121)
  4. 2 stars3% (68)
  5. 1 star13% (251)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 291-300 of 1,340 reviews
Apr 9, 2022
member2011
1 out of 5 stars review

not edible do not buy

on 4/7/2022, I bought a pack of this cod fillet for $ 25.59. The package looked fantastic. But the fillet was pre treated with STRONG preservative, rendered it nothing but an extremely salty taste, totally inedible. I will try to ask for a refund will update when completed.

Helpful?2113GU5SE61W13904360383
Oct 21, 2022
retreatmama
5 out of 5 stars review

Ordered 2, but received 1

I appreciated the Cod fillet, however, I ordered 2 cod fillets the day before and yet received only 1 cod fillet. Since I gave you 24 hours, I had hoped that I could get 2 cod fillets. I didn't go in the store to see if there were more on the shelves. That has happened to me before, but today had been a long day, so I didn't want to go in the store. The cod fillet was a gift, so I don't know how it turned out. But it looked good and fresh.

Helpful?2113GU5SE61W13904360383
Jan 25, 2024
MrJax
5 out of 5 stars review

American Cod - Delicious!

I love it. I will only buy it if it's wild caught off American water, say around Alaska or between Russia and the US. It must also be harvested in the USA. Canadian waters, Icelandic and Norwegian waters are fine. I am very pleased us carry this cod, it's delicious.

Helpful?2113GU5SE61W13904360383
May 25, 2024
Fabulous
4 out of 5 stars review

Awesome Cod fish to Eat.

The taste is awesome and priced to buy. This white fish knocked ** off of my feet. Really! Cod is beautifully mild, and this preparation couldn’t be easier ** more stunning. Coat it ** paprika and a few other spices, then pan-fry the cod until tender and juicy. It takes minutes to get restaurant-quality flavor!

Helpful?2113GU5SE61W13904360383
Aug 22, 2022
CutiePi333
3 out of 5 stars review

Buyer Beware

Purchased the Cod Fillets last week; they were very fishy smelling when I opened the package although the freshness date listed was several days out. I washed, dried and froze the fillets in several freezer bags and thawed in the fridge. The fishy smell when I prepared them was overpowering, but the flavor was good.

Helpful?2113GU5SE61W13904360383
Jan 8, 2025
Tucker
2 out of 5 stars review

Smelled awful

Oh, the ammonia smell coming from this fish is just awful!!! My partner boiled the cod in water with a little sugar to get the smell out (then baked with paprika and butter). The fish physically looks fine but stinks. I will NEVER purchase it again.

Helpful?2113GU5SE61W13904360383
Jun 12, 2024
Elizabeth
2 out of 5 stars review

Unusual for Sam’s fresh fish: Not so great cod,

It was very fishy smelling. Seemed old. We ate it that night and it didn’t make anyone sick, but we all agreed we didn’t want to save what was left over. Pretty disappointed because we have bought it before and liked it. I buy salmon, fresh and smoked, fresh tilapia and fresh trout regularly, and those have always been great. Won’t be trying the cod again any time soon!

Helpful?2113GU5SE61W13904360383
Apr 24, 2021
CJB
1 out of 5 stars review

Off odor & off taste

This fish was purchased with a use by date 6 days beyond the day I got it. I prepared it that day and noticed an odd smell and texture upon opening the package as well as after cooking it. It went straight into the garbage can. My money was fully refunded without question. I definitely know fresh seafood and this Cod was past prime.

Helpful?2113GU5SE61W13904360383
Mar 20, 2025
Tim N
5 out of 5 stars review

Excellent

Prepared them 2 ways...1 batch fried in lard and the other air fried (both versions dipped in egg, then a 50%-50% flour/panko mix) both came out fantastic. No shrinkage at all in either version. Moist and flaky just as you would expect. My personal fav was the batch fried in lard...with tartar sauce on a kaiser roll. Omg!

Helpful?2113GU5SE61W13904360383
Dec 28, 2021
Bink
1 out of 5 stars review

Extra fishy cod.

I cooked it last night. It was disgusting. It tasted way too fishy my kids wouldn’t eat it and we used to get the cod filets all the time at the sams club in Kissimmee. They were excellent. The kind at lake mary/Sanford are probably why my stomach hurt and I’ve had gas all day.

Helpful?2113GU5SE61W13904360383